Windows IT Pro is the leading independent community for IT professionals deploying Microsoft Windows server and client applications and technologies.
  
  
  Advanced Search 


June 09, 2006

WinInfo Short Takes: Week of June 12

RSS
Subscribe to Windows IT Pro | See More News and Analysis Articles Here | Reprints | Or get the Monthly Online Pass—only $5.95 a month!

WinInfo Blog

Short Takes
- Microsoft Concocts Yet Another Reason to Love Windows Genuine Advantage
- Microsoft Ships Windows Compute Cluster Server 2003
- Users Freaking Over Vista Battery Life Issues
- DOJ to Force Internet Search Companies to Save Data
- Vonage Sued by Investors
- AMD's Advantage Vanishes When Core 2 Released
- Yahoo! Messenger Support Coming Soon to Windows Live Messenger
- Microsoft Expands into Book Search
- Microsoft Celebrates TechEd 2006 with Worst Patch Day in Months
- Saying Goodbye to an Old Friend, Who, Frankly, Has Worn Out His Welcome

==== WinInfo Blog ====

by Paul Thurrott, thurrott@windowsitpro.com

Well, Microsoft has made Windows Vista Beta 2 available to the public. I think that's a mistake, because Beta 2 is buggy, unreliable, and unstable, and I've been having crazy performance issues with it on multiple systems. That said, if I know the typical WinInfo reader like I think I do, you're downloading it now. So I figured I should at least provide you with a few comments about the experience you're about to have.

First, understand the stages of beta testing. After the initial excitement comes the waiting, as it takes far longer to install Vista than you thought it would. Then, the first boot, and the excitement returns. Then, you install applications and go through a rollercoaster experience of highs and lows as applications either do or do not install properly. Then, reality sets in: The more applications you install on Vista, the bigger your chances of problems. And don't get me started on sound card drivers. Hey, what's a blue screen among friends?

Know that you're going to need a DVD burner to create the Vista DVD from the downloadable ISO. If you're foolhardy enough to download the x64 version, you'll need a dual-layer DVD burner with dual-layer media. You've been warned.

The version you're testing is Ultimate Edition. That means it has every single feature you can get in Vista, including a few that'll be cut from the final version. Actually, some features are missing too, such as Virtual PC Express. The point is, the version you're testing now includes features you won't see in the version you'll probably be running a year from now, because Microsoft will price Ultimate Edition like it's a door prize at a Republican fundraiser. Don't get TOO used to it.

Do not, under any circumstances, upgrade a perfectly good copy of Windows XP to Vista Beta 2. There is a special place in hell for people that foolhardy. Again, you've been warned. Do, however, consider dual booting XP and Vista. That way you can get back to a working OS when Vista inevitably does something so egregious that you never want to look at its translucent glass interface ever again. For me, it was the third blue screen in 30 minutes, after which I lost an accumulated page or so of text in Word. Anyway, I can't give you a quickie guide to dual booting here, obviously, but you'll need an extra partition or hard drive on which to install Vista. Have it ready before you start the install.

Here's my best Vista tip: If you do decide to dual boot, you can trigger the install in two ways: from within XP, or by rebooting the computer and booting from the DVD. If you use the former method, XP will be on the C drive and Vista will be on the D drive on both installs by default. However, if you install by booting from the DVD, XP will be on the C drive while you're in XP, and Vista will be on the C drive while you're in Vista. The latter is preferable, I've found.

Finally, consider waiting for Release Candidate 1 (RC1). I know you won't, and you know you won't, but you'd free up a lot of time and save yourself some anger and frustration if you could wait. I would wait, but you know, I have this job to do. Sometimes, I wish things were different. Sometimes.

==== Short Takes ====

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news

by Paul Thurrott, thurrott@windowsitpro.com

Microsoft Concocts Yet Another Reason to Love Windows Genuine Advantage

I was sitting around the other day listing all the things I just love about Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA), Microsoft's antipiracy tool. But then I discovered a hidden WGA feature that I'd never heard about, mostly because Microsoft had kept it a secret. It turns out that WGA actually connects to a Microsoft server every time you boot your PC. That's right. It's spyware. Microsoft actually installs a tool on your PC that does nothing more than check to ensure that you're not pirating Windows, and it does this check every single day and then sends the results back to Microsoft. This insidious behavior was first discovered by Lauren Weinstein, the co-founder of People For Internet Responsibility, and it's touched off a debate about disclosure and privacy. But seriously, this situation is ridiculous. It's bad enough that we're treated like pirates. Do we have to be spied on every single day as well?

Microsoft Ships Windows Compute Cluster Server 2003

Microsoft this week finalized its high performance computing server, Windows Compute Cluster Server 2003 (WCC03), which it'll begin shipping to customers in August. WCC03 is designed to take the complexity out of high-performance clustered computing servers and will let Windows Server compete with the big boys for the first time in scientific, military, government, and research markets. Some of Microsoft's early adopters are heavy hitters in the energy, science, and aerospace markets, and the company has a wide range of partners and developers backing the product. But I have to wonder. Is there some reason this thing has to have "2003" in its title? That was three years ago.

Users Freaking Over Vista Battery Life Issues

There's a big debate going on right now about Vista and battery life, or to put it more correctly, Vista and the lack of battery life. Turns out Vista gets a lot less battery life than does XP on identical notebooks, and many users are pointing to Vista's hardware-accelerated 3-D UI as the culprit. I have no doubts about that assertion, but I'd also caution people to remember that Vista is still a beta, and performance work is still to come. Microsoft says it'll improve Vista's battery life, but I have to think that its battery life will never be as good as that of XP, unless you turn off Aero Glass. And at that point, why bother running Vista?

DOJ to Force Internet Search Companies to Save Data

The US Department of Justice (DOJ) is trying to force Internet search companies such as Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo to retain customer use data for up to two years so that the information can be used to help catch sexual predators and terrorists. The agency has met privately with the companies, privacy groups, and children's advocacy groups so that everyone understands what it's trying to achieve. We can expect Google to complain about this requirement and fight it in court. After all, it bows only to governments that commit massive human rights violations.

Vonage Sued by Investors

When Internet phone company Vonage went public last week, it was supposed to touch off a new round of online euphoria. But something horrible happened. Vonage's shares closed down during its initial public offering (IPO) and then the company's stock lost 30 percent of its value in the first week. Here's the problem: As part of its New Age image, Vonage had given its users the chance to purchase 13.5 percent of its IPO shares. But because the stock has declined so sharply, those people will lose money. Many are threatening not to pay for their shares, and a group of shareholders is now suing the company. And, in a final nod to Bizarro world, Vonage is investigating whether it can sue those customers who don't pay for the shares they requested. Yikes.

AMD's Advantage Vanishes When Core 2 Released

According to leading hardware analysts, AMD's technological lead over market leader Intel will evaporate when Intel ships its Core 2 Duo line of processors later this year. A slew of independent benchmarks pitting Intel's upcoming chips against AMD's best microprocessors might provide AMD with some sobering news. Not only are the Intel chips faster, but they're much cheaper in many cases and suck up less power. AMD has enjoyed a multiyear lead over Intel in such technologies as multicore processors and x64 compatibility. But with the Core 2 Duo, which will ship in variants for notebooks, desktops, and servers, Intel seems to have finally caught up and even surpassed AMD in many meaningful ways (but not, curiously, in x64). I hope that AMD has a few surprises left. We all know what happens when you wake the sleeping giant.

Yahoo! Messenger Support Coming Soon to Windows Live Messenger

I've gotten a few email messages recently from people wondering when Yahoo!'s Messenger service will be integrated with Microsoft's Windows Live Messenger, the next-generation MSN Messenger. This week, Microsoft revealed that it's been working on integrating the services and will soon ship a software update that'll let Windows Live Messenger customers communicate with their buddies using Yahoo! Messenger. Given that we can expect to see Windows Live Messenger in final form late next week, according to reports, maybe that will also be the date when the integration happens. You never know.

Microsoft Expands into Book Search

In its latest bid to copy everything Google does (I hear it's even trying to out-capitulate Google in China), Microsoft this week announced that it's expanding its book search service to better compete with a similar Google service. I don't have more to say about this; I was really just looking for a way to work "out-capitulate" into Short Takes.

Microsoft Celebrates TechEd 2006 with Worst Patch Day in Months

Next Tuesday, Microsoft will unleash 12 security patches on customers as part of its regularly scheduled Patch Tuesday. And good news, folks: Many of the patches will fix critical security problems. This is the largest number of patches since February 2005, and given some of the problems we've had with recent patches, I'm sure users will be a little more leery (not to mention weary) about installing them. Hey, it could be worse. Wait, could it actually be worse?

Saying Goodbye to an Old Friend, Who, Frankly, Has Worn Out His Welcome

Customers still running Windows 98 and Millennium Edition (Me) have one more month to go before Microsoft finally pulls the support plug on these aging and increasingly dangerous OSs. The company will issue its final patches for Win98 and Me on July 11, the next Patch Tuesday, and then it'll stop providing security patches for them altogether. Anyone still running these systems deserves the computing equivalent of a Purple Heart. I wonder if Microsoft hands those out.

 

 

End of Article



Reader Comments
Like a fool, I am burning the Vista ISO image to a DVD as I type this. Thanks, Paul, for the dual boot tip. Good advice.

mwrisner June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


what could be worse is for them not to release patches.

also, how is microsoft's fault that the video card sucks up juice? blame nvidia and intel. They should provide a "low power mode" for the gpu just like intel does for the cpu so that it only uses as much juice as it needs to.

It's like saying doomIII hurts battery life. well duh!

guruguru June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"Beta 2 is buggy, unreliable, and unstable, and I've been having crazy performance issues with it on multiple systems. "

This is probably not a profound prediction but I would be very suprised if Vista was not delayed again. There is less than 6 months left and it still not very usable. Microsoft is going to have to pull a rabbit out of their hat to finish. It really sucks for developers because we have all these new cool developer tools but no platform to target.

"Microsoft actually installs a tool on your PC that does nothing more than check to ensure that you're not pirating Windows"

I bet Balmer is behind this stupid idea. Why do software companies think if they put strict copy protection on software that they will increase revenue significantly?

anonymous June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"Microsoft actually installs a tool on your PC that does nothing more than check to ensure that you're not pirating Windows, and it does this check every single day and then sends the results back to Microsoft."

I'm not condoning this behavior, but everyone in the press has gotten it out of context. Paul's statement is also innacurate since this isn't the "only" function this tool performs.

To the best of my knowledge (call it educated intuition), the check executes *only* when your machine visits windows update, or when your machine attempts to do an auto-update.

Since most machines are set to "auto-update", they'll look for updates every day, thus run the check. The verification "hand-shake" occurs every time your computer does anything with the update server.

If this *really* gets under your skin you can get around it by turning off auto update.

Christopher June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"Microsoft says it will improve Windows Vista's battery life, but I have to think it will never be as good as that of XP"

Once again there is a bit of a factual problem. None of the battery-life argument has anything to do with Microsoft. It ultimately NVidia and ATI's problem... The architecture of modern video cards cause significantly greater power consumption since the 2D logic and 3D logic is physically distinct. In XP and prior windows versions, the chip could pretty much throttle down large portions of it's innards when in 2D mode.

In 3D mode, the entire chip is operable, ergo you'll be generating tons of heat and wasting massive power. If you have heat-sensitive fans, you'll need to get used to the fact that Windows can now spin those up rather than just an FPS game.

Notebook chips are a little better since they can usually do dynamic clock throttling. However, as a rule, ANY OS that uses a 3D rendered UI will have worse battery life than other OS'es that do not.

This problem will eventually go away as the aforementioned graphics firms learn how to properly architect their product to run in an always-on 3D environment.

Honestly, my biggest concern is going to be increased electricity bills, increased noise (heat-sensitive fan), and potential premature failure of graphics chips.

Some of those massive $599 graphics cards put out inordinate heat. They may have seen their 3D duty cycles go from 20% to 100%, so I don't know what this might mean for video card failures. It depends how closely the manufacturers specify their cards against their thermal design limit.

I'm also suspecting this is why companies with a full 3D OS don't include the fastest boards (Apple -- they tend to step down a level or two from the top), potentially this is due to the heat/noise issue. Apple is currently the only company that would need to cope with this problem, and their market share isn't enough to cause the necessary fundamental architecture shift.

Christopher June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


You would be surprised, I am not downloading vista right now, and I am not going to do that. I have tuned my XPs with vista theme and I am quite pleased with that for the moment. :-)

Oh... and one more thing... Win98 SE is very popular round here (means Central Europe). I guess lot of people won't be happy...

alnag June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


After 15 years of being the first kid on the block with a new OS (starting with OS2) I ain't gonna load Vista. I've matured a bit and just don't want to fuss with blue screens, buggy software and reboots any more. I have Win2K at home and XP at work and both are running just fine. Maybe in 2 years when Vista SP1 is out I might give it a try. But for now, I'm gonna "out-capitulate" and go take a nap.

sparky795 June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


Where do I sign up for the award? :) I'm suprised my primary system, running 98 SE, is still running. I don't have access to a computer that will even run the Vista Beta :(, so I've got an excuse not to install it.

LibertyandJustice June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"This is probably not a profound prediction but I would be very suprised if Vista was not delayed again. There is less than 6 months left and it still not very usable."

Actually, less than four months. They need to get it out to businesses etc. by October end. That doesn't give them too much time. I too am beginning to have doubts. I may be wrong, but considering how much work is left to be done, I don't think it'll ship on time.

shark47 June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


Keep in mind that this beta was released in the latter half of may; internal builds are probably much farther ahead of the public beta. When MS gets ready to ship a build, they have two lines of code: the bugfix version of the build they will release, and other, further ahead builds for internal use.

I hope their internal builds are light-years ahead in driver performance and compatibility! I really want Vista to succeed.

NateB2 June 09, 2006 (Article Rating: )


 See More Comments  1   2   3   4 

You must be a registered user or online subscriber to comment on this article. Please log on before posting a comment. Are you a new visitor? Register now




Top Viewed ArticlesView all articles
What You Need to Know About Microsoft's x64 Server Product Plans

What do Longhorn Server, Windows Compute Cluster Server, and Windows Vista have in common? The x64 platform. ...

Anti-Virus Vendors Prepare for War with Microsoft ... Again

When Microsoft announced its Windows Live OneCare security and PC health product over five years (as MSN OneCare), Symantec, McAfee, and the other consumer-oriented security vendors reacted with stunning vigor. ...

Command Prompt Tricks

One reader shares his tip for setting up the command prompt to reflect a remote path. ...


Related Events Check out our list of Free Email Newsletters!

News and Analysis eBooks Getting Maximum Performance from Your Web-based Applications

Business Process Automation - Managing Cost in Your Enterprise

Related News and Analysis Resources Introducing Left-Brain.com, the online IT bookstore
Looking for books, CDs, toolkits, eBooks? Prime your mind at Left-Brain.com

Discover Windows IT Pro eLearning Series!
Clear & detailed technical information and helpful how-to's, all in our trademark no-nonsense format

Test Drive IT Solutions and Get Free Music Downloads
Solve your toughest IT problems with these free downloads and receive 5 free music downloads!


Windows IT Pro Home Register FAQ for Windows WinInfo News
Europe Edition About Us Contact Us/Customer Service Media Kit Affiliates / Licensing  
SQL Server Magazine Office & SharePoint Pro DevProConnections IT Job Hound ITTV
IT Library Technology Resource Directory Connected Home asp.netPRO Windows SuperSite 
 
 Windows IT Pro is a Division of Penton Media Inc.
 © 2009 Penton Media, Inc. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Reprints and Licensing