Tomorrow, palmOne will unveil two new consumer-oriented PDA devices in a bid to continue its recent track record of releasing innovative, hip high-tech accessories. Unfortunately, palmOne's offerings will debut on the heels of one of the worst quarters in PDA history. Despite two consecutive quarters of sales growth in late 2003, PDA sales fell almost 12 percent in first quarter 2004, year over year, to 2.2 million units.
palmOne's Palm OS-based devices retained the top spot last quarter, with 39.4 percent of the market. HP, which sells devices based on the Microsoft platform, was number two with 24.7 percent of the market. Sony, a Palm OS licensee, was number three with 9.3 percent. Dell and Toshiba, two Microsoft licensees, rounded out the top five with 7 percent and 2.2 percent of the market, respectively.
A few years ago, these numbers seemed a bit more important. But it's increasingly obvious that the PDA market is on the wane as consumers and knowledge workers move to more sophisticated multipurpose devices such as smart phones and Tablet PCs. Although palmOne still holds the number-one spot in its market, an obvious question arises: With the recent popularity of multifunction cell phones and smart phones and the rise of Tablet PCs on the high end, do traditional PDAs still offer unique value?
palmOne thinks so, although the company's purchase last year of Handspring, which makes the multipurpose Treo smart phone product line, suggests it wants to be ready in case the market changes dramatically. This week's new palmOne products, however, are very much traditional PDAs. The Zire 31 ($150) and Zire 72 ($300) offer color screens, improved personal information manager (PIM) applications, MP3 and photo-viewing applications, stereo headphone jacks, and expansion card slots, giving them a healthy multifunctional bent. The high-end Zire 72 also features Bluetooth networking, a higher-resolution screen, a built-in 1.2 megapixel camera, and other enhancements.
The question is whether these colorful, people-friendly devices can do anything to rejuvenate PDA sales. In addition to the aforementioned 12 percent drop in year-over-year sales, PDA sales plunged 33.1 percent between fourth quarter 2003 and first quarter 2004, a post-holiday sales drop that's larger than the market typically experiences. In the United States, PDA buyers are moving toward low-end products, such as the Zire family, whereas traditional business users are moving toward smart phones.
With its powerful Windows Mobile-based OS, which powers devices such as the Pocket PC, Microsoft was expected to eventually dominate the PDA market. But the market's move to smart phones might have forestalled and ultimately denied Microsoft that domination. Microsoft's smart phone entry, although well received by reviewers, has seen little traction thanks to resistance from traditional cell phone companies who are fearful of the software giant's motives.
The Tablet PC--a step up from the PDA--is poised to explode, however. Tablet PCs got off to a slow start in 2002 but recent changes to the underlying platform--thanks to the Intel Centrino mobile technology--have dramatically enhanced the devices' battery life and processing power. And a free OS update, due in late June, will improve the Tablet PC's handwriting integration. The Tablet PC market is one area in which Microsoft will no doubt dominate but it's also a traditional PC market in which the software maker has obvious advantages. And if the Tablet PC is successful, its functionality will become the prototype for all mobile PCs.
End of Article
I had the Kyocera smartphone for 18 months and was less than delighted to find out that it is no longer being supported. The new smartphone costs five times what I paid for my short-lived model. On the other hand, I can obtain a free phone every two years under my cell contract. Am I in a hurry to get another smartphone . . . not until they are dirt cheap, as my first one was.
Geraldine B. Reed April 28, 2004
I am personal asst. and confidant to an executive who just discovered the joys of the iPod. I have had a TREO 300 for a couple of years and a high end Sprint account for about 5 years. I am in no hurry to change everything and begin again, yet, I would give (almost) anything to find a way for these two units to communicate. Can install anything on my - or his - device that will enable us to "Hot-Synch", or something like it??? Thanx for the opportunity to ask. MM
Michael McCarthy April 28, 2004
The real reason the pda market is collapsing is that the machines never lived up to their hype. I have three, a casio, one of those old credit card pdas, and a Ipaq. I still use the ipaq but it absolutely refuses to interface with any of my computers or laptops. I downloaded synch software repeatedly but nothing works. I hear rumors on the net that my problem is not that unusual. My IBM workpad z50 works fine, but it does not sync either. So I am done buying these toys and will get a tablet pc in the future or an OQO if it ever materializes.
cliff farides April 28, 2004
This is an unbelievably slanted article towards Microshaft... give me a break. Talking about the PDA market's woes then in the same breath stating all kinds of hopeful crap about tablet PCs becoming the baseline for all mobile PC's? Please... give us >all< a break.
Editor's note: I'm curious why you see it that way. I don't expect "Microsoft smartphones" to dominate the "smartphone" market. Naturally, Microsoft makes the OS behind Tablet PCs, but then they also make the OS behind virtually all laptops as well, so if laptops all become tablets, nothing changes there at all. Microsoft slanted? --Paul
Jim Blithedale April 28, 2004
As a Tablet PC user, I tend to agree that PDAs, as a class are *likely* to be squeezed into a tiny niche market by both SmartPhones (MS-tech and otherwise) and TabletPCs.
But...
First, we need to see a usable $1000 wireless Tablet PC (new, not refurbished) and/or we need to see the release of the half-size 8" screen mini tablets. Preferably both in the same product.
At *that* point, you replace a 2 Lb paper planner (or hardcover book, for students) with 2 pounds of pure XP computing power and don't look back.
But price is crucial.
Regular laptops can be had for well under $1000; Tablets need at least one product there to get the message out that Tablets are not just for handwriting recognition...
Felix Torres April 28, 2004
I suspect that some of the targeted consumers for PDAs are buying iPods instead . . .
Imagine when Apple releases an iPod with cellphone (and perhaps video) capability - bye bye PDA . . .
BP Brodie April 28, 2004
I think the PDA market is lacking the so-called "killer app" that will make it an item that everybody wants. So far, consumers tend to stay at the low-end of the PDA pool (or opt for smart phones) while business consumers still prefer to go with traditional laptops or tablet PCs.
C. Morton April 28, 2004
I thought this was a "news" site, not a marketing channel for the Pocket PC and Tablet PC. How did we get from news about the Palm to cheerleading for Microsoft? The amount of uninformed speculation in this article is just amazing. "Microsoft was expected to eventually dominate the PDA market." Who, except Paul and Microsoft, expected this? "The Tablet PC...is poised to explode..." With the pathetic sales figures for these devices, it'd be more likely that the device itself would physically explode, rather than these things taking over the market. Oh wait, since Paul, in a seperate thread, has concluded that major market analysts don't measure verticals, like the Tablet PC, we'll just never know, will we?
John F. Braun April 28, 2004
It seems somewhat arbitrary to say "iPod with cellphone" or "cellphone with pda". It's just a matter of perspective, after all. They are all just computers, so they should naturally merge - just as TV and computer merge in the DVR.
None of this "bye bye xxx", but instead "hello improved device".
b. ewbank June 30, 2004
You must be a registered user or online subscriber to comment on this article. Please log on before posting a comment. Are you a new visitor?
Register now
While Microsoft is still investigating a notebook battery life issue that was supposedly caused by Windows 7, some interesting trends have emerged. ...
Microsoft on Monday issued a lengthy statement about the recent Windows 7 battery controversy, echoing my assessment from earlier in the day, but backing it up with hard, cold evidence. ...
Should Your Email Live in the Cloud? This Forrester report shows how-to calculate your on-premise email costs and compare with cloud-based alternatives and offers best practices for reducing email costs.
New from Left-Brain.com - Manage VMware with PowerShell Learn how to perform everything from simple ad-hoc reporting at the command-line to complex scripts that automate a massive deployment of hundreds of virtual machines. Solve your old problems using less code than you thought possible!
Geraldine B. Reed April 28, 2004