WinInfo Short Takes, March 9, 2012

An often irreverent look at this week's other news ...

Ray Ozzie Says We're in the Post-PC Era

Microsoft's first and thus far only attempt to replace cofounder Bill Gates with another tech visionary failed mightily, and now that failure is speaking out about his thoughts on the post-PC world. Which is to say that Ray Ozzie—the guy who created one decent technology solution and then spent the rest of his life simply reinventing and re-releasing it—now says that the PC is dead. "Why are we arguing? Of course we are in a post-PC world," Ozzie said this week at a Seattle-area tech conference. "That doesn't mean the PC dies. It just means that the scenarios that we use them in, we stop referring to them as PCs, we refer to them as other things ... It's a world of phones and pads and devices of all kinds, and our interests in general-purpose computing—or desktop computing—starts to wane and people start doing the same things and more in other scenarios." OK, that's actually pretty reasonable. But the guy was still a massive failure for Microsoft, sorry. 

Surprise! PC Sales to Surge in Wake of New iPad. Guess Why!

So, Apple just announced its latest iPad, and of course the tech press is agog at the latest evolutionary product from Apple that looks identical to its predecessor, and I'm sure in some sad neighborhood somewhere, the usual group of lemmings is queuing up at a store to be the first to own a device that will be obsolete in 12 months. But don't believe for a moment that the iPad 3 is going to usher in the End Of Times (tm) for the PC world. In fact, according to Gartner, PC sales growth is actually going to skyrocket next year by about 10 percent. Why is that, you ask? Because Microsoft's iPad killer, Windows 8, will hit the market this year, accompanied by a full set of competitive slates, ultrabooks, and hybrid PCs that will do to the iPad what the PC did the Mac. At least, that's the plan. My guess is that iPads and Windows 8 devices will both sell pretty well going forward and that no clear winner will emerge. But it's fun to goad the Apple guys. In fact, it's a bit too easy. 

Nokia's Annual Filing with SEC Is a Bloodbath

Nokia filed its annual report with the US Security and Exchange Commission (SEC) this week and, well, it's not pretty. The company lost €1.4 billion in calendar year 2011, during a time in which it transitioned to Windows Phone. And its net sales were also significantly lower then the previous year, €38.6 billion vs. €42.4 billion in 2010, when it earned a profit of  €1.3 billion. On the good news front, Nokia still managed to sell 340 million handsets in 2011, just a 3 percent decline. But of those, only 77.3 million were smartphones, a drop of 25 percent year-over-year. Nokia noted in its filing that its transition to Windows Phone (from the failing Symbian platform) was fraught with risks and that it has no other plan to succeed. If you're interested in reading Greek tragedy, you can find the report in PDF format on the Nokia website. I guess time will tell if this was the beginning of the end or the darkest night before a new morning. Or whatever. 

iPad 3 Brings a Knife to a Gun Fight

Lost amidst all the normal hoopla that accompanies even the most evolutionary of Apple product updates is the fact that, retina display aside, Apple's latest iPad just doesn't have what it takes to compete with Windows 8. Why do I say that? Because the iOS 5 system that powers the iPad is horribly out of date and still the same stretched-up-from-a-phone OS it has always been. Unlike Windows 8, the iPad OS doesn't offer any real advantages on a bigger screen, and the navigation and app multitasking capabilities are rudimentary. Add that to the fact that the iPad, duh, can't run Windows applications and you have the makings of Apple's long-term approach of "doing the minimum with each update" finally being its Achilles Heel. I'm sure Apple will sell millions of these things—tens of millions—because, well, it's Apple. But this won't hasten the demise of the PC at all. In fact, I expect Apple to once again lose market share in the tablet market this year. And thanks to the iPad 3, the blame falls squarely on Apple. 

Microsoft: Sorry, but That Cool iPad App Running Windows Is Illegal

You might have heard about the innovative iPad app called OnLive Desktop that brings a free Windows 7 desktop, Office applications, and Adobe solutions to the Apple's consumer-friendly tablet. If not, check out my review of OnLive Desktop, which actually works quite well. Too well, one might say. Because Microsoft is now claiming that the product is essentially illegal. And that's because OnLive isn't paying for those copies of Windows and Office it's using. "The Services Provider License Agreement (SPLA) does not support delivery of Windows 7 as a hosted client or provide the ability to access Office as a service through Windows 7," Microsoft Corporate Vice President Joe Matz wrote in a blog post explaining how OnLive is violating Microsoft's licensing agreements. "We are actively engaged with OnLive with the hope of bringing them into a properly licensed scenario, and we are committed to seeing this issue resolved." OnLive has no comment, but it's fair to say that this wonderful app will soon change very dramatically.

Federal Government Looking to Sue Apple Over eBook Price Fixing

Remember when Apple illegally partnered with book-publishing companies to raise the price of ebooks and screw customers? Well, good news: The US federal government remembers that too. And now the US Department of Justice (DOJ) is prepping an antitrust lawsuit against Apple, accusing it of colluding with publishers to raise prices. Which it did. Sadly, I don't expect the average selling price of ebooks to go back to the proper and previous level—$9.99 for a new book—but I can dream, right? 

Microsoft Announces Plans to Shutter Windows Mobile Marketplace

About a year after it stopped accepting new submissions to its app store for the obsolete Windows Mobile platform, Microsoft this week revealed to customers that it would be shutting down the store on May 9. Windows Mobile, of course, has since been replaced by the more modern and interesting Windows Phone platform, although it's still unclear if this new system has the chops to compete with the iPhones and Androids of the world. But for the 7 or 8 people still mourning, or at least using, Windows Mobile, get in now while the getting's good. The party's almost over. 

Listen to Paul. No, Really Listen. Or Watch. Or Both!

This week, Andrew Zarian and I recorded the latest episode of the What The Tech podcast on Tuesday, and Mary Jo Foley, Leo Laporte, and I recorded the latest episode of the Windows Weekly podcast on Thursday. As always, these episodes should be available now or soon, generally in both audio in video formats, on the web, and via iTunes, the Zune Marketplace, and wherever else quality podcasts are found. You can also find all of my podcast activities on the SuperSite for Windows

The Paul Thurrott Mobile App: Is That a Paul in Your Pocket?

If you haven't seen them, we're now offering a Paul Thurrott: Pocket Tech app for both the iPhone and Windows Phone, bringing all of my technical content to your favorite mobile device in a fun, on-the-go format. We'll have an Android version available soon as well, I'm told. Download for Windows Phone - Download for iPhone.

But Wait, There's More

Don't forget to follow me on TwitterFriendfeedPaul Thurrott's SuperSite for Windows, and the SuperSite Blog. Coming soon: Windows 8 Secrets!

Discuss this Article 21

MysterMask
on Mar 10, 2012
NB: Why is it not possible to give a negative star rating for such drivel?
infiniteloop
on Mar 11, 2012
Thought this might cheer up all you WinFanGirls while you're waiting for W8OA. http://m.computerworld.com/s/article/9225077/Apple_runs_out_of_new_iPads_for_Friday_delivery?
MysterMask
on Mar 10, 2012
You definitively should change the tag line to "An totally irrelevant look at this week's other news ..."
BananaJr
on Mar 9, 2012
@ -Tayme Unfortunately as he falls further out of touch we are laughing at him and not with him.
infiniteloop
on Mar 9, 2012
Sorry Paul, but like most people not wearing the Microsoft blinkers, Ray Ozzie gets it.
wlow3
on Mar 9, 2012
"Ray Ozziethe guy who created one decent technology solution and then spent the rest of his life simply reinventing and re-releasing it." Change that to "copied one decent technology" and you'd have a description of Microsoft itself. " ... the usual group of lemmings is queuing up at a store to be the first to own a device that will be obsolete in 12 months ..." Most technology will be superseded in 12 months. The point is, unlike Microsoft's phone, people ARE lining up. "Apple's latest iPad just doesn't have what it takes to compete with Windows 8." Now just two paragraphs above he says he predicts BOTH tablets will sell well, so which is it? "In fact, I expect Apple to once again lose market share in the tablet market this year." What ... 1%?
infiniteloop
on Mar 9, 2012
Poor Paul. All the blather about Windows Phone being the new iPhone killer. Pah. Windows Phone market share actually decreased again by one percentage point last quarter. Face it. Windows Phone is never going to get any traction. Windows 8 for iPads, sorry, Tablets, is going to be a severe disappointment too. People are expecting to be able to run all their legacy Windows Apps on such a device, like they've always been able to before. Imagine the frustration when they realise they can't. Meanwhile Apple will likely have 200 million iOS devices out there before the first Windows 8 device hits. Paul knows this, hence the increasingly hysterical and over the top rants. By the way Paul, the failure of Windows Phone is partially responsible for Nokia's 'Greek Tragedy'.
ModernDislocation
on Mar 9, 2012
Paul's reporting is always fun for what he leaves out. The Gartner report that is cited as included a bit about how this year was supposed to be a big growth year for the PC but they have reduced their forecast due to .... wait for it..... the iPad! And we have this gem: "Apple's latest iPad just doesn't have what it takes to compete with Windows 8. " really...? A shipping product doesn't have what it takes to compete with a non-shipping product? Yeah, how could anyone compete with a nonexistent product?
JayZeee74
on Mar 9, 2012
The new iPad doesn't have what it takes to compete with a non existent product? You have got to be $h!tt!ng me!!! You seriously wrote that? Bwhahahahahah I have no words for the sheer insanity of that comment.
jkohut
on Mar 9, 2012
Thoughts: Nokia's plan B would be to continue with Symbian and/or Meego platforms. They have about 6 months to make that decision before those platforms have stagnated enough that they can not be resurrected. RE: Apple and Gun to Knife Fight. Many will disagree that it is a knife fight. 60% of the home users and 40% of the Business users could, with a little effort, use only a tablet for their needs. That is a big enough market to indicate that the Windows Dominance will at least subside. I agree it won't like go away in the near term (3 years). Onlive Desktop shows that Microsoft Products are popular, but my guess it Microsoft's prices will be unpopular. If Microsoft charges Onlive anything close to what they charge regular customers for Windows 7, MS Office, and associated CALs to run them, Onlive's Business Model will fall apart (which is why MANY don't adopt Microsoft Terminal Services and/or VDI model.
argraphics
on Mar 9, 2012
"Windows Phone market share actually decreased again by one percentage point last quarter" I guess Paul stop reporting Market share stats in this area.... ""But it's fun to goad the Apple guys. In fact, it's a bit too easy."" Paut T. The Rush Limbaugh of Tech....
MSTAYLOR
on Mar 9, 2012
"But it's fun to goad the Apple guys. In fact, it's a bit too easy." This is what I have been telling you all that Paul has been up to...still, he has a point and it works every time for him (and me).
mwagner@indiana.edu
on Mar 9, 2012
WOW! Where to I start? So much to talk about ... First up, the iPad. It came about as a natural extention to the iPod Touch/iPhone platform. By its very nature it was evolutionary - not revolutionary - and remains so today. Apple's success with the iPad is arributable to three factors - a $500 pricepoint (the same as entry-level PCs) - simplicity, through Apple's ecosystem - and portability. Android cannot compete at Apple pricepoints so they will always be second tier, with Amazon applying price pressure on the rest of the Android market. Lower pricing on the iPad 2 jus makes matters worse for Android. Only Amazon can offer as robust an ecosystem as Apple. Apple long abandoned the enterprise market place - preferring instead to sell to well-healed consumers but the iPad reset that market. Now Apple has indicated that it will bring more iOS-like capabilities to the Macintosh in order to stay competitive. Microsoft has recognized that it must response to the iPad or lose a lots of consumer business as well as some of the enterprise business among road-warriors and upper management. While Apple seeks to make the Macintosh more iOS-like, Microsoft has decided to bring Windows to the tablet. Windows 8 will do just that through a new Metro interface. The familiar Windows desktop will be available for more traditional PCs - and it will be available on Intel-Based tablets. The Metro interface will also be available for those wanting to use Metro applications. On ARM-based tablets, Windows 8 will offer Metro only, which will be direct competitin to the iPad. Further, there are indications that Micrisoft will ports its Metro applications to iPad Android. Whether or not this approach can stop the iPad juggernaut remains to be seen but it is Micrososft's bettle to lose. A quick comment about OnLive desktop. Ths technology is also available using perfectly legal Citrix virtualization technology. This example is an isolated license violation.
trieste
on Mar 9, 2012
@tayme Are you saying that Paul is now the Rush Limbaugh of tech journalism?
BallmerGates
on Mar 9, 2012
I love that Paul spends his time trolling Apple users at the expense of makin himself look like a bumbling buffoon. Looks like the buffoon is doubling down on his "iDud" prediction after it's already overtaken the world's largest PC maker's entire product line in shipments and profitability.
reunson
on Mar 10, 2012
"Pad 3 Brings a Knife to a Gun Fight" At least the iPad is razor sharp and a decent weapon. Microsofts gun is a civil war era powder fired musket which they tried to update by mounting a laser sight on top. Whats more the laser sight is mounted 90 degrees to where the gun is pointing so it therefore a convoluted mess that doesn't work.(Metro & Desktop UI) Meanwhile, the iPad knife has quietly stabbed and killed everybody before Windows 8 could get the powder loaded. (Still waiting for those Windows 8 tablets Paul. When are they coming? Late 2012? 2013 for ARM? Windows 8 won't be up against iOS 5, it will be up against iOS 6)
chuckb84
on Mar 10, 2012
What are others saying about Windows 8? Well, here's one: http://www.infoworld.com/d/consumerization-of-it/the-windows-8-tragedy-how-microsoft-can-avoid-disaster-188047?page=0,0 And it's worth quoting at length, "Every time Microsoft has a new OS, it changes the UI. If the UI were based on legitimate usability testing, it wouldn't need such radical changes every few years. That constant level of significant UI change simply means Microsoft is still getting it wrong. Compare Windows to Mac OS X, which had a major retooling 12 years ago. It has evolved dramatically since, but no one has ever had to relearn the Mac UI from version to version. A Mac user from 20 years ago would recognize the fundamentals in today's version, as different as they may appear on screen. That should have been the history of the Windows UI as well. I saw a Microsoft presentation this week on Windows 8 and all its glories. The marketing exec painted a vision of thin laptops and tablets as what Windows 8 would make possible. As I looked around the conference, I saw dozens of MacBook Airs, scores and scores of iPads, and scads of iPhones and Androids. I also saw a lot of rolling eyes as the Microsoft rep continued to embarrass herself with clueless claims. That future Microsoft pretends it's inventing already exists, and today's reality is far ahead of Microsoft's "vision." The foks in Redmond need to stop telling each other how wonderful they are. The emperor has few clothes left." Of course, Paul's livelihood depends on NOT see any of this, so he never will.
nim55
on Mar 9, 2012
Paul has a long history of comparing real Apple products to vaporware Microsoft products. Witness his article below from 2009: "Rumors Surface of a New Microsoft Tablet Design" Paul Thurrott, 9/23/2009 "While the Apple-loving press holds its collective breath for what is expected to be an early 2010 announcement of an iPod touch-based tablet computer, the real deal is coming from a company with almost of a decade of tablet PC experience. Microsoft is now in the final stages of developing a book-like tablet device (code-named Courier) that completely rethinks the concept of personal computing. Microsoft's Courier device uses a so-called "booklet" form factor that provides two 7" color screenssimilar to an open book. The screens are multi-touch (of course), support gestures and cross-screen copying, and work with either fingers or stylus-like pens. ... Microsoft released the first version of its Tablet PC-based OS software back in 2002 and has been innovating in this space ever since. ...Put simply, this is not technology that Apple invented or even came to market with first. But you'd never know that from reading traditional news sources. That said, although Microsoft did get there first, Apple is the only company with a truly successful touch-based interface. The Apple iPhone dominates the consumer smart phone market in the United States, and its iPod touch is one of the best-selling MP3 players ever created. But if Microsoft's Courier project looks as good in the real world as the prototypes do, expect it to send Apple racing back to the design labs."
trieste
on Mar 9, 2012
"...then spent the rest of his life simply reinventing and re-releasing it" says the writer of Windows Vista Secrets, Windows 7 Secrets, Windows Phone Secrets and the much-anticipated Windows 8 Secrets.
MSTAYLOR
on Mar 9, 2012
@trieste - More like Bill Maher...only funny.
jkohut
on Mar 9, 2012
Thoughts: Nokia's plan B would be to continue with Symbian and/or Meego platforms. They have about 6 months to make that decision before those platforms have stagnated enough that they can not be resurrected. RE: Apple and Gun to Knife Fight. Many will disagree that it is a knife fight. 60% of the home users and 40% of the Business users could, with a little effort, use only a tablet for their needs. That is a big enough market to indicate that the Windows Dominance will at least subside. I agree it won't like go away in the near term (3 years). Onlive Desktop shows that Microsoft Products are popular, but my guess it Microsoft's prices will be unpopular. If Microsoft charges Onlive anything close to what they charge regular customers for Windows 7, MS Office, and associated CALs to run them, Onlive's Business Model will fall apart (which is why MANY don't adopt Microsoft Terminal Services and/or VDI model.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.