WinInfo Short Takes: February 10, 2012

An often irreverent look at this week's other news, including Microsoft's incredible but overdue revelations about Windows 8 on ARM devices, why the tech press is wrong to deride Nokia for not having a Plan B, a hypocritical Barnes & Noble won't let antitrust claims against Microsoft sit, the Xbox 360 continues to reign over a sad and diminished industry, an ironic Ethical iPhone movement sweeps across a hypocritical world, and Google is making a consumer electronics device that is not in any way interesting.

I'm in a mood this morning. Strap in.

WOA! Look Out Apple, Microsoft is Getting the Tablet Right

After months of silly silence in the face of hundreds of legitimate questions from customers, businesses, developers, and the tech press, Microsoft suddenly and unexpected unveiled (most of) its plans for ARM-based Windows 8 tablets. I've got the details (of course) in Microsoft Finally Explains Windows 8 on ARM: Desktop and Office 15 Applications Will Be Included, as well as an accompanying screenshot gallery. But the big takeaway here is simple. Windows on ARM, or "WOA," as Microsoft calls it, looks like more than a credible answer to the iPad. In fact, it looks like something that will relegate the iPad to the backwater of the tablet market, much as Windows did to the Mac. And they will ship with full, but touch-enabled, versions of the coming Office 15 apps, which should be a neat final nail in the coffin of those overpriced luxury items from Cupertino. Last year, the Kindle Fire proved that a low-priced device could quickly chip away at the iPad's dominance. This year, ARM-based Windows 8 tablets are going to accelerate the iPad's decline. And I'm not the only one who thinks so.  This is a big deal, people. The only question is why Microsoft sat on this for so long. Windows on ARM looks awesome.

Why the Tech Press is Biased, Part 281: Nokia Has No "Fallback Plan"

If I were to tell you that Microsoft had no "fallback plan" in the OS market in the sense that, if Windows suddenly nosedived, they weren't secretly working on a version of Linux or something, you'd quickly intuit that this statement was ludicrous. So why is it OK to claim that Nokia, which embraced Windows Phone as its smart phone OS last year, likewise has no "fallback plan"? That's exactly what the tech press is doing this week, based on a comment from Nokia vice president Victor Saeijes, who replied "Plan B is that Plan A must succeed" when asked whether there was a Plan B. Why would there be a Plan B? And why is it OK to criticize this company for having a plan? They're not RIM for crying out loud. That company's Plan A is to continue failing with the same strategy it's always used. Nokia, at least, has made a big bet. Now back off.

Barnes & Noble Seeks Reversal in Microsoft Ruling

Those prickly never-pay-for-patented-technology eBook reader makers at Barnes & Noble just won't let the Microsoft thing drop. The company this week said it would seek a reversal of a US International Trade Commission (ITC) ruling that dismissed B&N's antitrust-based "patent misuse" claim against the software giant. Heads-up, Barnes & Noble: That claim is so 1998, and the Microsoft of today is many, many miles away from the recalcitrant industry behemoth that wrecked other businesses 15 years ago. In fact, if I'm mistaken, the last time you were in the news, it was for putting independent, small book  stores out of business. So pay up, or answer in court, and stop the whining. And you had to know Android was pretty risky. You didn't really think it was free, did you?

Making Lemonade: Xbox 360 Still Number One in January, But the Video Game Market has Imploded

Imagine you've just won a nuclear war, but the entire planet has been destroyed. That's the Xbox 360 in January 2012. Microsoft this week crowed that its video game console was number one yet again in January, and number one for all of 2011. But the Xbox 360 rules over a decidedly unhealthy market, with video game industry revenues plunging an unprecedented 38 percent, year over year. Analysts, weighing in from their ivory towers, say the slide had a lot to do with the lack of any major new games being released in January, though I'd point out that the month after Christmas is generally a slow release time for any consumer products. See how easy it is to "analyze" this? Frankly, I'm amazed anyone bought an Xbox 360 in January, let alone one of its even more lackluster competitors. It's only a matter of time before Wii consoles are falling out of cereal boxes. This generation of devices is spiraling down the drain.

Irony Alert: Ethical iPhone Movement Sweeps Across the World

This is what happens when a significant chunk of the population is unemployed and has nothing to do: They pretend to care where, and in what conditions, in which their expensive digital baubles are made. It's cute, and it's silly, but yes, Apple really is the biggest offender here, by far, since its products are incredibly successful. And Apple, unlike its competitors, goes way out of its way to claim they're ethically made when in fact they're not, which should be a warning sign. The issue here is simple: Apple makes absolutely illogical margins on its popular electronic devices almost solely because they're made in Chinese sweatshops where workers are ill-paid, overworked, and, go figure, have a curiously high suicide rate. And now some of its many fans are starting to see the irony in Apple's squeaky-clean image, though I'd frankly point the finger at them for taking so long to notice. I mean, where did you think these things came from? Did you believe Unicorns were building them in their spare time between rainbow parties? I bet Apple could make every single one of its devices in the US, using high-priced US workers, and still make a heady profit. Will they do it? Of course not. And that's everything you need to know about Apple in a nutshell. Now either live with that fact, or don't. But don't pretend Apple is doing anything differently than other companies or that you actually care about people in China. And for crying out loud, don't upgrade your unnecessary consumer electronic devices every single year as if on cue. Again, the problem isn't Apple. It's you, the Apple customer. Think globally, please. But act locally. Stop buying crap you do not need.

Google Working on Vague Consumer Electronics Device

And speaking of crap you do not need, Google is in the news this week because it is allegedly working on "a home entertainment device" that would move the company further into Apple's core market of abusing Chinese workers. But where are the details? According to a New York Times report, the device is Google's "most significant venture into hardware." It will stream music at first, and eventually do more. So ...  what? They're making a Roku device? Seriously, does every company in the tech industry have to just copy what every other company is doing? Do I really need to remind you that Google is responsible for Google TV, a series of devices so bad that it actually punished its users more than the Chinese workers who made it? Are we really going to pretend to be interested or excited by this product? No. We are not.

Listen to Paul. No, Really Listen. Or Watch. Or Both!

This week, Andrew Zarian and I recorded the latest episode of the What The Tech podcast on Tuesday, and Mary Jo Foley, Leo Laporte and I recorded the latest episode of the Windows Weekly podcast on Thursday. As always, these episodes should be available now or soon, generally in both audio in video formats, on the web, and via iTunes, the Zune Marketplace, and wherever else quality podcasts are found. You can also find all of my podcast activities on the SuperSite for Windows.

But Wait, There's More

Don't forget to follow me on TwitterFriendfeedPaul Thurrott's SuperSite for Windows, and the SuperSite Blog. Coming soon: Windows 8 Secrets!

Discuss this Article 20

ModernDislocation
on Feb 10, 2012
I agree that human rights should be a concern of any and every company and there should be no debate on that. I am less inclined to say that the size of the company or their position in the market somehow makes them more responsible than others as in my mind there really isn't much wiggle room in how seriously a company should take the issue. I do find Paul's part time human rights activism to be sicking as it lacks in any sort of insincerity. If, as tayme says the industry leader is responsible for shouldering the burden then let's hear Paul talk about the industry leader in the world of mobile phones. That would be Nokia and not even by some small margin. The same nokia that Paul currently cheerleads for and the same nokia that has their phone's make in the same foxconn factory as the iPad and iPhone. So, Paul are you in are you out on human rights or are the only important when it comes to attacking Apple and the sweatshop is A-OK to make the phone you like?
chuckb84
on Feb 10, 2012
"But the big takeaway here is simple. Windows on ARM, or "WOA," as Microsoft calls it, looks like more than a credible answer to the iPad. In fact, it looks like something that will relegate the iPad to the backwater of the tablet market, much as Windows did to the Mac. " Yah, right. I see you're doubling down on the pathetically funny "iDud" prediction. WARM may have some success. People who spend their days poking at Office software may like the Office that is included with WARM, but the iPad 4 and iOS 6 will be the competition for these gadgets. iPad is here to stay.
reunson
on Feb 12, 2012
"Apple really is the biggest offender here, by far, since its products are incredibly successful. And Apple, unlike its competitors, goes way out of its way to claim they're ethically made when in fact they're not, which should be a warning sign. The issue here is simple: Apple makes absolutely illogical margins on its popular electronic devices almost solely because they're made in Chinese sweatshops where workers are ill-paid, overworked, and, go figure, have a curiously high suicide rate." So what should consumers do Paul? Should they buy WP7/8 phones instead from Microsoft & Nokia instead? In that way they can be assured that MS and Nokia are making less profit. Is that right? Hence, the offending will be less? After all, Apple is the biggest offender, by Paul's logic. Total lunacy.
jkohut
on Feb 10, 2012
Nokia currently has two plan Bs that could and are doing as well as Windows Phone. They are Symbian S^3 (current version is Belle) and Meego. Meego, being a Linux based OS, could still easily be salvaged and extended. What Stephen Elop (or more importantly Nokia's Board) need to do is be able to continually assess the success of Windows Phone and not wait until it is too late to consider revisiting those platforms. I am not saying that it is LIKELY that Nokia will have to fall back on Meego or Symbian (they say they NEVER will). It is going to be interesting to see if Nokia starts to see a lack of success from Windows Phone and puts some level of effort back into Meego or Symbian.
jazzdog
on Feb 11, 2012
"Windows on ARM, or "WOA," as Microsoft calls it, looks like more than a credible answer to the iPad. In fact, it looks like something that will relegate the iPad to the backwater of the tablet market, much as Windows did to the Mac." Do you actually believe this garbage? What world are you living in? You seem to feel that you cannot appreciate a technology or business that is not from the Church of Microsoft. It is pathetic. You can't accept the fact that Apple has trumped Microsoft. Microsoft now has a chance to make a dent in the tablet market, good for them and I hope they do exceedingly well, but nobody in their right mind would think that iPads will be 'relegated to the backwater'. It's called ecosystem. Apple is the gorilla here, like Microsoft used to be on the desktop. Difficult to take you seriously.
gocheif
on Feb 10, 2012
FYI: Almost all Samsung and LG products are made in Korea (ROK). Korea is a first world country where working conditions are good and that may explain the difference between Apple and Samsung's profit margins...
de Silentio
on Feb 10, 2012
Paul: "So why is it OK to claim that Nokia, which embraced Windows Phone as its smart phone OS last year, likewise has no "fallback plan"? " The difference is that Windows OS has a next to zero chance of failing. Windows Phone on the other hand... There's the old idiom "don't count your chickens before the eggs have hatched". Well, the eggs for Desktop Windows have hatched, Microsoft has counted them, and Microsoft is profiting from them. The eggs for Windows Phone are still incubating. If Nokia doesn't have a Plan B (i.e., an android solution backup), then they have already counted their chickens and will be in deep s hit if Windows Phone doesn't take off. In my opinion, you drew a poor analogy for the reason I indicated.
chuckb84
on Feb 10, 2012
As for WARM (or WOA, whatever), Microsoft has made a bet, which is that it's tablet strategy is Windows, Windows, Windows. This was pretty much their only play, especially this late in the game, and anyway, it all comes down from the top. Ballmer, just a couple of months ago: "We are in the Windows era," he said. "We were, we are, and we always will be. " So, no surprise. Of course, to get in the game they now have to GIVE AWAY Office! This totally undercuts their leading profit center, making it irrelevant in the fastest growing device category. This is a strategy of losing money on every sale, but making it up in volume. Now people can pick, do they want Windows with multitouch bolted on or Android or iOS? Neither of those competitors will be standing still, so I hope Microsoft can move fast, but that's not a strong point up in Redmond. As for all the criticism of Apple over supply chain labor conditions, who can disagree? But, Paul practically makes a fetish of Apple's "low market share", so it's hard to see how Apple is the big evil monster. They're not. That said, they do have a better and more visible Bully Pulpit for this issue than anyone else, so they have a responsibility to use it. However, Paul's hypocrisy on this issue is even worse than his usual petulance, and that's saying a lot.
forkieboy
on Feb 10, 2012
Irony alert. More disingenuous rubbish. To describe Apple as the worst offender is risible. Most major first world companies use the third world in the most offensive manner. Slave labour and lack of environmental controls to produce the products. And then the unwanted / superceded products are sent back to the third world to further pollute it. There is little ethical in first world business. We can all attempt to minimise the damage, but few are willing to do the research or pay the price. I am not an Apple apologist, but at least they are making an attempt.
jersey72
on Feb 10, 2012
tayme- It is a shame as this was a great place to track where things were going. Now it's just Paul bashing Apple and lots and lots of trolls.
infiniteloop
on Feb 13, 2012
Apple now worth more than Microsoft and Google combined. That should send Paul completely over the edge.
chipwinter
on Feb 10, 2012
I'm particularly excited about the ARM tablets running Windows 8 because Microsoft usually gets it right the first time.
ITguy107
on Aug 5, 2012
I can't believe someone can be so oblivious to reality.
wlow3
on Feb 10, 2012
Irony Alert: A Tech writer with a house full of tech chastising others for owning tech Paul not only owns tech but specifically Apple tech as well, as he has mentioned over the years; so maybe that pointed finger ought to do a 180. All the sweatshop criticisms are valid, but let's not forget that Apple was late to the sweatshop party, following Dell, HP, et al. Apple originally had their factory in California (and NeXT's factory was in California, too) until Tim Cook came on board. FoxComm was already in business, but the scrutiny of their practices only intensified as Apple's profile increased beyond the other PC manufacturers. Where was Paul then?
gruverja
on Feb 11, 2012
In the same paragraph, you say "Apple makes absolutely illogical margins on its popular electronic devices almost solely because they're made in Chinese sweatshops where workers are ill-paid, overworked, and, go figure, have a curiously high suicide rate" and "But don't pretend Apple is doing anything differently than other companies". Which is it, Mr. Thurrott? Is Apple exploiting the workers spectacularly badly, or are they exploiting the workers no differently than every other consumer electronics firm is doing? You can't have it both ways.
BananaJr
on Feb 10, 2012
@Meh You have just uncovered Paul's dirtly little secret. Microsoft has fallen behind and Paul can't address it because he's cornered himself addressing the direction of Windows vs. the direction of IT. We are dumping 10s of thousands of desktops in favor of thin clients, phones and tablets on the frontend. No Microsoft be be seen. MIcrosoft has not only fallen behind on the consumer side but VMWare and Citrix are eating them up in virtualizing the backend too. So now we still use plenty of Windows Servers and license the client but we use VMware or Citrix to serve it up and iOS, Android and Linux to consume it. And Windows tablet? Please, we have thousands of them in our retail stores and are in the process of dumping those too. By the time WOA comes out we will have moved on. Too little too late. Microsoft has great products and great people but too often managment ties their hands and prevents truely innovative products to emerge. Everyone is too busy protecting their fiefdoms to allow it. So now Paul is left to trot out tired Apple/Android snark to direct everybody's attention away from the real problems at Microsoft. I for one hope both get a clue but am increasingly sceptical.
MSTAYLOR
on Feb 10, 2012
Regarding WOA - Time will tell. Will the public see it that way or will they continue to see the iPad and then everyone else? Regarding Chinese manufacturing - Apple is the industry leader. That comes with some responsibility. That does not absolve other manufacturers from also forcing change...but Apple can and should drive this one. Regarding Paul's column - This column has become more about consumer electronics than Windows IT. It's interesting stuff, but does not fit the title and the history. I'll be reading less and less of it.
infiniteloop
on Feb 13, 2012
Paul. Please stop this ridiculous ranting. My sides hurt.
jersey72
on Feb 10, 2012
Cue the local residents going nuts over Paul's Windows 8 & iPad comments...
hawg16
on Feb 10, 2012
I quote Delmar in O Brother, Where Art Thou?: "I'm with you fellers." I rarely come here any longer as it's not much of a column for IT information any more. However, it's pretty amusing to see the Apple trolls lose it over the slightest insult (perceived or otherwise). Friday's column is usually a good time to read for the entertainment factor alone.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.