WinInfo Short Takes, August 24, 2012

An often irreverent look at this week's other news ...

The Colors in the Microsoft Logo Do NOT Represent Individual Products

Since Microsoft unveiled its new Metro-inspired corporate logo yesterday, I’ve been inundated with theories about which products each of the four colors in the symbol part of the logo represent. Folks, those colors do not represent individual products. (And stop trying to match blue to Windows, red to Office, green to Xbox, and yellow to … what? Yellow?) According to Microsoft, “the symbol’s squares of color are intended to express the company’s diverse portfolio of products.” And that’s it. Microsoft doesn’t make four products. It makes many products. There’s no need to look for meaning beyond that.

IDC: Windows 8 Will Jumpstart PC Growth, But Not This Year

The market researchers at IDC are now claiming that the release of Microsoft’s hotly debated Windows 8 OS will do nothing to jumpstart PC sales in 2012, so PC makers will need to wait for 2013 for a miracle. “The worldwide PC market is now expected to grow just 0.9 percent in 2012,” the firm claimed in a report issued this week. “367 million PCs will ship into the market this year, up just a fraction of a percent from 2011 and marking the second consecutive year of growth below 2 percent.” According to IDC, consumers are “waiting for Windows 8,” which won’t ship until October 26, and the inference seems to be that any post-Windows 8 bump will be offset nicely by the current quarter, where PC sales are expected to be very, very slow. “There is likely to be some confusion among buyers about new product features as well as where they will get the most for their money,” the report added, apparently suggesting that more choice could in fact be bad for sales. Before anyone gets too excited by any of this, I’ll just point out that these supposedly omniscient brainiacs are forced to revise their crazy predictions every time actual sales numbers come in. So this report, such as it is, amounts to a mulligan since their previous predictions were all horse-puckey to begin with. Remind me: Why do we listen to this stuff again?

Is Microsoft Censoring Windows 8 Criticism?

A BetaNews report levels a pretty serious charge against Microsoft: The site claims that the software giant issued what is essentially a bogus Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) take-down order to remove criticism about Windows 8 from on an online forum. The basis for the complaint is that someone in this thread used a screenshot from Microsoft’s Windows Team Blog to demonstrate why the complaint about the Windows 8 UI was valid. “Some of your materials allegedly infringe upon the copyrights of others,” a Google forwarding of the DMCA notice reads. “We are in the process of removing from our Google Search results the materials that allegedly infringe upon the copyrights of others. If we did not do so, we would be subject to a claim of copyright infringement, regardless of its merits.” Why is this bogus? Because it’s obviously fair use to take an image posted by Microsoft in a public forum and use it in other public forum as part of a debate about the merits of the product’s design. And while Microsoft has in fact filed several other DMCA complaints aimed at websites that are critical of Windows 8, it hasn’t done so against any that are complimentary. Put another way, Microsoft is simply trying to erase criticism of Windows 8 online by usurping an unrelated US law. At least that’s the charge, from what I can tell.

Yes, Verizon, There Really Is a Windows Phone

Bloomberg is reporting that Verizon will finally get its Windows Phone game on with a new Windows Phone 8 device made by Nokia. The wireless giant has, to date, sold only one Windows Phone handset, a now hopelessly obsolete first-generation HTC Trophy. But after spending the past year or so griping about LTE and other nonsense (read: jealousy of AT&T Wireless), Verizon is going to man up. The plan, Bloomberg says, is for Verizon to sell a Nokia Lumia device running Windows Phone 8 starting sometime this fall. That said, Verizon won't be part of Nokia’s event early next month, which will no doubt queue further jealousy of AT&T because AT&T is expected to be in attendance. Of course, AT&T, unlike Verizon, hasn’t been shy about embracing Windows Phone, which explains the cozy relationship there.

Korean Court Rules that Samsung Did Not Copy Apple Designs

Well, I guess there’s no need to wait for that US federal jury to return a verdict in the Apple/Samsung design-copy case: A South Korean court has already decided that Samsung did not, in fact, copy Apple’s designs with its own products. "It is not possible to assert that these [Samsung] designs are similar based only on the similarity of [certain] features," the court’s ruling reads, noting that the design of individual icons in Samsung’s products did not resemble icons in Apple’s iPhone. (This assertion was part of the US case as well.) Samsung also won a ruling that determined that Apple’s iOS products infringe on five Samsung patents. The court also ruled, however, that Samsung infringed on one Apple patent related to the “bounce” effect that occurs when a user scrolls to the bottom of a list using touch. Punishments in the case are minor. Both firms must pay the other tiny amounts in damages. (Samsung will pay Apple about $22,000, while Apple will pay the other firm a bit more.) And until any issues are rectified, older Samsung and Apple products—but not current-generation products—will be banned for sale in the country.

The First Time I’ve Ever Wanted to Live in China

IDC today reported that Apple’s iPhone is coming up blank in at least one locale. Sales of the trendy iPhone have tanked in China, with sales in the quarter ending in June falling a whopping 50 percent. Chinese customers bought 44 million smartphones in the quarter, but the big winners were Samsung, which leads the market with about 19 percent market share, and Lenovo, which kicked Apple out of second place with about 11 percent of the market. Apple, stumbling to third place, controlled about 10 percent of the market. Why does this matter? Two reasons. I’m tired of the iPhone, which has been out of date since the release of the iPhone 4S and which lacks LTE, a reasonably sized screen, and other necessary figures. And China is set to become the biggest market for smartphones in the world this year, overtaking the United States.

Listen to Paul. No, Really Listen. Or Watch. Or Both!

Back on a normal schedule this week, I recorded What the Tech with Andrew Zarian on Tuesday and Windows Weekly with Leo Laporte and Mary Jo Foley on Thursday. Both podcast episodes should be available soon, on the web, and via iTunes, the Zune Marketplace, and wherever else quality podcasts are found. You can also find all of my podcast activities on the SuperSite for Windows.

The Paul Thurrott Mobile App: Is That a Paul in Your Pocket?

The Paul Thurrott: Pocket Tech app is now available for both the iPhone and Windows Phone, bringing all of my technical content to your favorite mobile device in a fun, on-the-go format. We'll have an Android version available soon as well, I'm told. And who knows? A Windows 8 app would make plenty of sense too. Download for Windows Phone - Download for iPhone

But Wait, There's More

Don't forget to follow me on TwitterFriendfeedPaul Thurrott's SuperSite for Windows, and the SuperSite Blog!

 

Discuss this Article 45

scottm99999
on Aug 26, 2012
Call me cynical if you will, but no one ever competes on merit. Not Apple, not Microsoft, nor any other hardware/software vendor. Marketing & advertising are there to sway people to buy products/services over another vendor.
hawg16
on Aug 24, 2012
"But you are not a cheerleader for MS." I wouldn't say he's a cheerleader for MS. He does have an irrational hatred towards Apple though.
infiniteloop
on Aug 25, 2012
And the winner is: The consumer. Now there will be real choice because Samsung et al. will have to compete by differentiation and innovation and not by slavishly copying other people's (not just Apple's) innovations. Imagine if Samsung had won. Multiple imitations of the class leading devices. At least now, devices will have to compete on merit. It's healthier and more exciting. Oh, and Android is in deep, deep trouble.
infiniteloop
on Aug 26, 2012
@R: What a strange world you live in.
jersey72
on Aug 24, 2012
Only pretty stupid?
spaul40
on Aug 24, 2012
Paul: You have been saying for over six months that an Android app may be coming soon. Just how many million android phones have to be out there for you guys to realize you're missing a potential good market? Your pro MS comments can only help to increase people's attitude toward MS. It didn't take that many Apple "nuts' to get that ball rolling to the juggernaut that it is.
nim55
on Aug 24, 2012
Oh, Bummer. This Samsung-Apple news is going to ruin Paul's weekend. I'm not a lawyer and I haven't been following this case very closely, but it was pretty obvious that a lot of Samsung's icons and stylistic cues were inspired by Apple's designs. Again, I'm not a lawyer and I don't know how close is too close in regards to getting into legal trouble with copying. But it does seem like Samsung could have been more careful in making sure that their icons and other stylistic cues did not appear too similar to Apple's designs. In particular, Samsung's icon for the phone application was a blunder. It looked like a near-exact copy of Apple's design. Samsung didn't have to do that. They could have easily come up with many other icons just as stylish to represent the phone app.
infiniteloop
on Aug 27, 2012
@R: I'd look for another career if I were you. If that's what IT as a career does to you.
airport_toilet
on Aug 24, 2012
BANG!!!!!!! 1 billion, 51 million 855 thousand dollars Free drinks on me im at Faltering Fullback in swinging London 19 Perth Road N4
jkohut
on Aug 24, 2012
RE: Microsoft Logo and Colors It is obviously clear that they are the 3 Primary colors + Green. Green is for MONEY ! @Anonymous, I appreciated your prediction of responses. Since there is no "like" option here, consider this a "Virtual Like"
jersey72
on Aug 24, 2012
Couple of thoughts... I do find it amusing that our resident troll[s] are following this and posting at 1a their time. @Banana- I'm very curious to see what Paul does with this. You very well may be right. :-) There's still a good couple of years left to this battle. Samsung has plenty of grounds to appeal on and, of course, they will. I also find it very interesting that of the 9 jurors, only 4 had smart phones. Anyway, it's time close the laptop and find that glass of bourbon that has my name on it. Cheers everyone!
infiniteloop
on Aug 24, 2012
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444358404577609810658082898.html Innovation is safe.
chuckb84
on Aug 24, 2012
"Chuck will flip his lid over the words "Apple", "Tanked," and the phrase ""The First Time I've Ever Wanted to Live in China". Possibly have a stroke." :). No. The man is delusional. Not worth commenting on.
BananaJr
on Aug 24, 2012
No mention of Nokia's flubbed China relations? It's too bad Apple is your favored target. Imagine the fun you could be having at Microsoft's expense with Windows Phone right now.
jersey72
on Aug 25, 2012
@tayme: As always, they are the only true winners.
scottm99999
on Aug 27, 2012
After many years in I/T, and dealing with countless vendors (big & small)...that's just the way I see it.
jersey72
on Aug 24, 2012
"The First Time Ive Ever Wanted to Live in China" Wow - biased much? I think that's probably one of my favorite Paul paragraphs where he doesn't even try to pretend to hid his vitriol towards Apple. "Korean Court Rules that Samsung Did Not Copy Apple Designs" http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444812704577608242792921450.html Not quite, Paul. The court did rule Samsung violated a couple of Apple patents, just not all of the ones Apple said they did. My question is this - will the resident Apple fans now come down hard on Apple for copying Samsung? (Rhetorical question, really)
jersey72
on Aug 24, 2012
So the verdict is in, which is amazing. Sweeping victory for Apple. Cue the appeals by Samsung. And as always, this is still far from over (if it ever does end).
McGilli
on Aug 24, 2012
Didn't anyone else read the part here about Apple losing ground in China and say "WTF Lenovo makes phones?" Am I the only one who didn't know that?
hawg16
on Aug 24, 2012
"My question is this - will the resident Apple fans now come down hard on Apple for copying Samsung? (Rhetorical question, really)" My predictions: infiniteloop will post negative links about MS, positive links about Apple that no one will click and ignore the fact that Apple copied Samsung (as per the Koreans) thus confirming he is a hypocrite. Chuck will flip his lid over the words "Apple", "Tanked," and the phrase ""The First Time I've Ever Wanted to Live in China". Possibly have a stroke. Yoshipod will take an hour or so to put together a long rebuttal. Lawyers will win, consumers lose, and the world will keep on spinning.
scottm99999
on Aug 27, 2012
Probably just me...I do I/T now to support my scuba diving hobby :) Heck, if I could make a decent living with scuba, I'd do it!
BananaJr
on Aug 24, 2012
I guess there is a need to wait for the jury verdict in the US case. And I'm sure this will get spun as a Samsung win since Apple did not get the sweep or $2bil
MSTAYLOR
on Aug 24, 2012
....and the winner is.....the lawyers!
argraphics
on Aug 24, 2012
"The First Time Ive Ever Wanted to Live in China" Speaking from a family that came from a Communist Country with a horrible human rights record. I can say your comment is pretty stupid.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.