Nokia Quickly Identifies Lumia 900 Software Flaw, Sets Things Right

When customers complain about a recently released flagship smartphone, there are apparently two ways to respond. You can pretend there isn’t a problem and stage an elaborate event with lots of hand waving and redirection. Or you can address the problem quickly, and do right by customers. Nokia has chosen the latter approach.

Remember Antennagate, when Apple’s iconic iPhone 4 was found to suffer from an endemic hardware design flaw that caused massive signal loss when the device was held in a commonly used way? And remember how Apple pretended it wasn’t a problem and then actually held a press conference that fooled many in the press into believing it wasn’t a problem?

Yeah, Nokia’s not doing that.

Just three days after the Finnish smartphone giant released its flagship Windows Phone handset, the Lumia 900, Nokia revealed that there was a software flaw that could, in some cases, lead to temporary data-connectivity issues. And instead of ignoring the problem, telling customers to wait for some future update, or holding a press conference with lots of hand waving and redirection, Nokia is instead doing something unexpected. Something noble.

Nokia is doing the right thing.

Those who did purchase the Lumia 900 already—it debuted exclusively on Sunday on AT&T Wireless in the United States—can hold out until Monday, April 16, when Nokia will deliver a software update that fixes the problem. Or, you can swap your phone for an updated Lumia 900 that doesn’t exhibit the problem. In either case, everyone who did purchase a Lumia 900 will receive a $100 credit to their AT&T bill from Nokia.

According to a post to the Conversations by Nokia Blog, the issue doesn’t even affect all Lumia 900s already in the market. And it can easily be fixed with a software update. “A memory-management issue was discovered that could, in some cases, lead to loss of data connectivity,” the post notes. “This issue is purely in the phone software, and is not related to either phone hardware or the network itself. As a proactive and prudent measure, we decided to take immediate action. We have identified the issue and have developed a solution.”

I hope Apple is taking notes, because this is how you respond to valid customer complaints. Not by telling them to hold the phone differently or by staging an elaborate event that tries to redirect the conversation to other topics. You respond by doing the right thing.

Discuss this Article 18

jersey72
on Apr 12, 2012
I'm not exactly sure what I had to do with this conversation, but ok... I don't need to "unprove" myself a "Liar" because that would require me being a liar or proven a liar in the first place. Again - we had the conversation. That you can't find it doesn't change the facts. I don't feel like having the exact same conversation again. And I'm done having this conversation as well.
inge2go
on Apr 11, 2012
infiniteloop - ..."the iPhone Antenna non-issue was just that. A non-issue. All phones attenuate a signal depending on how you hold it." Apple, though a bit late, did admit that is was an issue. I suppose that it then is the right thing agree with them.
infiniteloop
on Apr 11, 2012
Uh Oh: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/eca6adcc-83f4-11e1-82ca-00144feab49a.html#axzz1rl5NWAdU Interesting comment about consumers not wanting Windows Phone. I'm surprised the penny didn't drop sooner.
hawg16
on Apr 11, 2012
@Meh, Yeah it's (Paul's Apple rants) pretty much old and eye-glazing. A lot like infiniteloop's posts, weirdly enough! Do you suppose it's really him?! HAHA! I've more or less stopped coming here as regularly as I used to due to the vitriol over Apple and the fanboys that have pretty much taken over the comment board. Also, the lack of meaningful information on IT subjects that used to be here. As for the phone, I have yet to find a device that handles integration with Exchange (our Messaging server of choice) anywhere close to BlackBerry, so I'm eagerly awaiting their next (perhaps last if it fails) effort to see how it goes. I hear that the interface is supposed to be awesome on Win Phone, but I haven't had a chance to see it in action. If it's anything like Win8, I'm fairly unimpressed by it on a laptop. Have to see it work on a tablet I guess.
MSTAYLOR
on Apr 12, 2012
Hook, line, and sinker.
McGilli
on Apr 11, 2012
If after 3 days of Apple releasing an iPhone, they needed to reimburse every purchaser $100, how much would that cost them? $100,000,000? $200,000,000? $300,000,000 Now. After 3 days of release, how much will Nokia have to pay out if they provide all purchases $100? $1,000? $10,000? $100,000? See, when you play in the big leagues, it's not as easy as just "doing the right thing". While I DO agree that Nokia has done the right thing, it also completely damages their Hero phone's image. I didn't trust Microsoft products before the Lumia launch, and I REALLY distrust them even more now.
fjmahoney
on Apr 11, 2012
Of course doing the right thing will go a whole lot further if the update actually fixes the issue.
infiniteloop
on Apr 12, 2012
--tayme: A toilet break, I take it? Re:Suffering. Nope. Not suffering from a Lumia that cannot connect to the Internet. Not suffering from a keyboard that disappears unexpectedly. Not suffering from any Windows issues. Not suffering from viruses or malware. In fact. Not suffering at all. I cannot imagine what you could mean. Apple make the best Laptops, Tablets, Music Players, Phones and desktop computers. They also make the best Operating System, have the biggest Music Store, App Store and Apple TV works a treat. With all that going on, where is the suffering? I'm still waiting for Meh to unprove himself a Liar.
infiniteloop
on Apr 11, 2012
@Inge Larsson: I'm sorry but I have absolutely no idea what you are trying to say.
infiniteloop
on Apr 11, 2012
This is not Nokia's problem. It's Microsoft's. Nokia is not responsible for the software. Microsoft is. Paul, the iPhone Antenna non-issue was just that. A non-issue. All phones attenuate a signal depending on how you hold it. A software issue however, is very different. It stops you from doing things. First the disappearing keyboard. Now this. It's Amateur hour again, it seems. @fanboyssuck: Your steadfast support of Blackberry is commendable if out-of-date. Pity RIM aren't going to be around for much longer, eh?
jersey72
on Apr 11, 2012
I'm just going to ignore all the normal Paul attacks on Apple, because, well, he wouldn't write this article any other way. You have to give credit to Nokia for this extraordinary step, essentially giving everyone a "free" 900 for their troubles. Of course, in the end what it really points to is how desperately both Microsoft and Nokia need this phone to be a success. Basically, if the 900 doesn't sell well it's game over.
hawg16
on Apr 12, 2012
@infiniteloop Uh oh. Could it be that you're about to fall off your high horse? Probably not, 'cause you're part of the RDF, but for what it's worth: "Apple works on Mac malware fix but takes heat" http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/12/us-apple-trojan-idUSBRE83B00H20120412
hawg16
on Apr 11, 2012
@Meh I'm running it on a Lenovo T500. It's snappy, but using a mouse to do anything is really screwy so far. Also, and this may be my lack of experience with it, you have to tie it to a Windows Live account. Kind of silly in my opinion, but I haven't added it to the domain yet. I'm not impressed with the overall look of it, but then I remember going from DOS to Windows 3.1, (there, I aged myself) and thinking the same thing. I've read that there are a ton of kerboard shortcuts that make getting around a very quick and awesomely fast thing, so I'll give it another shot here and see. As for the phone, I would love to get my hands on one to try, but it's pretty tough where I am and the phone I have seen are (sorry for the pun) "meh" at best. I do have an iPhone (personal) that I love, but it has issues with the calendar and some other minor things that the Blackberry I have (work) doesn't. However, if I can convince the powers that be to give it a try, I will (for work) for sure.
hawg16
on Apr 11, 2012
Keep saying the antenna isn't an issue, infiniteloop. I have the iPhone 4 and it happens EVERY time I hold it that way. For reasons I don't need to divulge, I hold my phone to my left ear all day and when I don't have the cover on it, I drop calls all the time. It's an issue despite your ravings that it isn't. Apple covered it up (literally and figuratively) and you know it. As for the windows phone comment, give it a rest. But since I don't own one, I won't make wild accusations (unlike you.) You may be right about RIM, but I suspect that they'll make money changing their business if they're smart. For example, making the iPad and iPhone actually be a proper, viable solution for the Enterprise via their BES product. You know, where Apple utterly and miserably fails to pay attention. Of course, they are busy sueing, counter-sueing, and fending off DOJ investigations into collusion issues with book publishers now aren't they?
nim55
on Apr 12, 2012
This is ridiculous. Nokia and/or Microsoft screw up and Paul turns it into some sort of diatribe against Apple? Huh? Let's stay on-point here. Microsoft and Nokia desperately need this and their other phones to be a big success. In order to grab any significant market share from the established competitors, Microsoft and Nokia need to show that their WP7 phones aren't just as good as Android's and Apple's. They need to show that the WP7 phones are clearly BETTER than the competition. Otherwise, why would anyone want to bother with a phone from a newcomer as opposed to a polished product from an established and experienced competitor? If I were in the market for a smartphone, this event would kill off any remaining interest I would have in buying a Nokia WP7 phone. No thanks. Don't want to be your beta-tester. Give me a call when you work out the bugs.
infiniteloop
on Apr 12, 2012
@MehLiar: It's very, very simple. You said that you had provided 'about 5' different alternatives to the 'Slide to Unlock' patent, as you said that unlocking a phone was a simple matter. Those alternatives do not appear in your posts. You mention other Patentable innovations, but nothing which is an alternative to the 'Slide to Unlock' patent, which, to spell it out for you, is about unlocking a touch screen phone. Unless you can copy and paste or repeat your 'about 5' alternatives, you are a liar. Simple. And anyone who cares to, can see for themselves.
MSTAYLOR
on Apr 12, 2012
It's easy and humorous to see who here will suffer the most because of brand loyalty and refusal to use what works best in a given situation...Paul and Kliloopi. What is even more humorous is watching Kliloopi trying to find those alternatives to the slider he was so desperate about a few days ago. It was so obvious, it was hidden from him. That was entertaining!
jersey72
on Apr 11, 2012
Re: phone - I made the switch to WP7 over the holiday and I love it. The app support is spotty in a few places, but the OS does laps around iOS. Oh - and no iTunes! Re: Windows 8 - I haven't installed it yet so I don't have a strong opinion one way or another. I am curious how effective it'll be on a non-touchscreen.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.