Windows XP Fights Piracy

In Windows XP (formerly code-named Whistler), Microsoft is instituting an antipiracy measure that will tie the product key to Microsoft Product Activation. The new measure will reduce casual copying by requiring users to register (aka activate) Windows XP over the Internet or by phone before using the product. Product Activation will create a unique identification code for each installation based on the product key and hardware-configuration criteria. If the user tries to install the same copy of Windows XP (i.e., software that has the same product key) on a different machine, the activation will fail. Product Activation is similar to the feature that Microsoft Office XP, which debuted this spring, uses. Windows XP is set to ship this fall.

"Consumers sometimes unwittingly violate their license agreement by sharing software with others," said Allen Nieman, the technical product manager for Microsoft's licensing technology group. "Through education efforts and the use of technology solutions like Product Activation, we're working to make sure that customers who choose Microsoft software products acquire genuine software and are eligible for technical support and product upgrades."

Microsoft says that Product Activation doesn't scan a user's hard disk or register the make and model of the PC with the company. Instead, the feature uses the product ID and hardware-configuration information to generate a random installation ID, which it then registers, along with the product ID, with Microsoft.

Users who are concerned that changing their system's configuration will affect the activation status of their Windows XP installation have nothing to fear: Microsoft understands that people upgrade components in their systems, and Product Activation accounts for this possibility. If a user completely recreates a system from scratch (e.g., simultaneously replaces the motherboard and other main components), the user must call Microsoft to activate the product when Windows XP's activation feature tries to reregister the OS upon reboot.

Microsoft designed Product Activation almost solely for individual licenses, so the feature won't affect most corporations, which typically purchase Microsoft products with volume licenses. Microsoft says that it will include Product Activation only in retail Windows XP versions or versions that consumers acquire through PC makers and other OEMs.

Discuss this Article 22

Joel (not verified)
on Jul 18, 2001
It stinks that if I add more memory, a faster CPU and a new CD writer, I have to get Microsofts' permission to use my PC(s) again.

We have 6 PCs in our house, it is financially prohibitive to upgrade them to WinXP/OfficeXP. There is no way I can afford to spend $2000+ for a software upgrade on 6 PCs. I would have had difficulty justifying the original cost of Win2K/Office had they not come pre-installed for a fraction of the retail price.
Anonymous User (not verified)
on Jan 16, 2005
I added two new sticks of ram and now i gotta register again. THAT IS BULL.
Anonymous User (not verified)
on Feb 21, 2005
What happens if you upgrade with a pirated version. What will happen after 30 days will it go back to XP home edition?
Donald e. Oinen (not verified)
on Jul 22, 2001
What do I get when I purchase Microsoft Windows XP. Do I get a license to run the software on a single unique computer or do I get a license to run the software on any computer I choose? If I purchase the software and choose to move it to a different computer will I be able to do so? What makes a computer unique? Is it the box, the power supply, the motherboard, the processor, ... ?
Achong007 (not verified)
on Aug 6, 2004
This is really annoying. If I change out the Motherboard or anything, I am forced to call Microsoft. The worst part is the 1 hour wait. How much long distants will that cost? Can I charge $9000 to Microsoft for waiting on the phone and the cost of my long distant bill? They have the nerve to charge us for everything else we get from Microsoft. What about my constutional rights to privacy? When I call, I will have to give them some of my personal information to reactivate my copy of windows. Maybe we should all go to Linix and make it user friendly to the point that its free. And stop buying Microsoft or any Microsoft related product. That's not the half of it. Every time Microsoft comes out with a new product there are always bugs. So many bugs that it is infested with cockroaches. So why should I pay 299 for a full version of the software with only one licence. I should get 5 free licences or licence to my own household only. Without Microsoft OS you will not be able to run any software that is out on the market at all. Now everybody is forced to have and use Microsoft. There is no other way around it! I wish the government would just go ahead and break up Microsoft because its way too big and very unfair. What about the Microsoft Internet Explorer. There are so many secerity holes in the browser that you can run a Aircraft Carrier through. And they complain about Piracy. No folks if you want to stop the Piracy then Microsoft has better start worring about taking care of the system flaws first. Then people will be more willing to buy the product instead of having a need to crack down on Pirate Software. Heck, I would not mind buying the software and just licence so much if the OS was not infested with giant cockroaches.
Mike Barton (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2001
Money, money, money. If Microsoft was in dire financial straits, I could perhaps understand the need to implement such draconian methods, but come on! I agree with Ray Smith's observation that piracy has helped fuel the widespread adoption of Microsoft Products and market domination. I just completed the Office Suite poll elsewhere on this website, and 73% of respondents are using Microsoft Office - the next nearest competitor, Wordperfect Suite held a whopping 5%! I realize this has nothing to do with Windows XP, but it reflects the massive marketshare that they currently hold. I think if Microsoft becomes this anal, the eventual loser will be them; not the pirates.
Achong007 (not verified)
on Aug 6, 2004
One last thing, if they really want to stop piracy then offer extra licences for 5 dollars each. I am sure that most people would not mind. Then, again Bill already gots too much money!!!
Carter (not verified)
on Jun 26, 2001
Windows XP fights piracy? I agree with the other posts. While this is a good idea "in theory", for the user who actually modifies ther PC on a regular basis, this is a major problem. I don't want to spend an hour on my cell phone waiting for some computer illiterate person to give me a stupid number. And judging by previous windows installations (and numerous REINSTALLATIONS due to the OS crashing) this is going to be a giant waste of time. I think if I even bother to try XP (which I doubt) after my first time being put on hold, when the tech finally answers, my response will be "sorry, while you had me on hold waiting for a stupid number, I accidentally installed Linux on the PC... and I think I don't need the stupid little number."
jenifyr (not verified)
on Jun 29, 2001
?piracy, this is coming back to the days of mainframes, yes you can have the hardware, but we will lease the software to you. This means I will need to spend time on the phone at least every 3-4 weeks to Microsoft. Great idea against piracy?, how come (I believe) this is not being implemented in USA and Canada. This is snooping of what I have on the PC, do we really know what information is being collected and coded in the generated key. Yes, yes, we do believe that Microsoft is not enforcing their monopolistic policies on us.
Ray Smith (not verified)
on Jul 10, 2001
By nature alone, many customers fear the PC itself in terms of how it works. Coupling what they do not know about the computer operations along what the XP install technology,I would not want to buy it either. Fear of the unknown. I personally believe that if people bummed software copies from others, that they would not have been potential paying customers anyway. Which brings me to the paying customers. Once I pay for it; its mine... and I do not need to have one more impediment to getting my system back up. I have to work with my system(s) and trust me, waiting on ill-informed representatives is no day @ the park. For out-of-box users it may not be so bad... maybe Microsoft can give up to 3 generated keys out per call. MS will have to change the way key generation occurs, but atleast "paying" customers can have their peace of mind when upgraging /repairing their systems. No fear of "checking-in" and "monitoring" your tendencies. How about our bottom-line and not yours.
john (not verified)
on Jun 29, 2001
I also upgrade my PC on a regular basis. I'm a student, so I'm always doing something to it. If I have to call Microsoft each time then forget it. I'll stick with Linux or FreeBSD.
victor cruz (not verified)
on Jun 16, 2001
The piracy feature sounds great with one exception. when i upgrade my computer I have to call microsoft to receive a new serial number. Here is the headache part, I call and then get put on hold for an hour plus just to get a valid serial number because I decided to upgrade my pc. this does not sound feasible. I have already had to wait an hour plus just to receive tech support on office xp. why not use the cd lock technology that some pc games have now like cd cloak and safedisc2. Red alert 2 is a perfect example that this technology works. not many people have successfully made copies of Red alert 2.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.