Feature for Feature: VMware ESX Server versus Microsoft Hyper-V

Virtualization Means Cost and Energy Savings

The Windows IT Pro editorial team looks at dozens if not hundreds of products every year, and picking one winner out of all those in a particular category is always a challenge. That predicament is further amplified when we consider a product for our most prestigious Product of the Year award. VMware ESX Server 3.5—a subset of the VMware Infrastructure 3 bundle—made our decision easy this year.

Virtualization has shaken the IT industry to its roots over the past few years, and no product influenced that sea change more than the ESX Server family. In an interview with Windows IT Pro, VMware President and CEO Diane Greene mentioned how virtualization is generating tangible, significant cost and energy savings for IT administrators. “We estimate that there have been at least six million workloads virtualized since 1998,” says Greene. “If we figure 7,000 kilowatt hours for every physical server that is virtualized per year, that goes to 39 billion kilowatt hours. \[That translates\] into about $4.4 billion saved, which represents enough energy to power Denmark for a year.”

Positive Changes for IT Infrastructure

In addition to the energy and cost savings that ESX Server 3.5 has generated, it has also helped radically redefine how IT pros manage their infrastructures. Michael Cisek, the director of emerging infrastructure and operations support for PITT OHIO EXPRESS, has relied on ESX Server 3.5 (and the VMware Infrastructure 3 bundle) to radically revamp his IT infrastructure. “We’ve been able to reduce our server pool using server consolidation, often at a fifteen-to-one consolidation ratio. Our server deployment time went from days or weeks to minutes and hours, thus reducing the overall development cycle of new products and application,” says Cisek. “We’ve also experienced zero-cost hardware replacements \[by using virtual machines\]; when equipment begins to fail, we perform physical-to-virtual server conversions … We’re also in the process of converting to a virtual QA infrastructure. Our goal is to have one-to-one representation of all mission-critical applications for QA and testing. Finally, our developers used to maintain multiple physical workstations: one for production, one for development, and one for QA. We’ve been able to consolidate all three of those functions onto one physical PC by using VMware Workstation.”

The impending arrival of Windows Server 2008 with Hyper-V will mean more competition for VMware in this rapidly growing market segment. If VMware can revolutionize the IT industry in an unopposed market, what can it do when motivated by an aggressive competitor? It’s shaping up to be an exciting battle, one that every IT administrator (and penny-pinching CFO) will be watching with interest.

—Jeff James

Discuss this Article 5

tkarp22 (not verified)
on Feb 12, 2008
comment
fotw2
on Dec 23, 2008
@ MarkEmery: how about registering/subscribing to Windows IT Pro? Then you can read all the articles...
jessew
on Mar 21, 2009
That was less than helpful, one of the better mis-leading headlines I have seen lately.
Mark (not verified)
on Jan 30, 2008
articles are always truncated. Don't know how to read the whole thing. It should be obvious... What a pointless web site this is.
Erick (not verified)
on Feb 26, 2008
Hi, Interesting thread and believe MS Hyper-V is making a big noise at the moment just as any other MS products when it get nearer to release date. Thanks for the Microsoft marketing team. For that our team have put a good initial comparison between Hyper-V vs VMware ESX at http://itcomparison.com/Virtualization/MShypervvsvi35/HyperVvsvmware35esx.htm and we are working on enhancing it daily and with information and concerns that added through our forum at http://itcomparison.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=41 Please have a look at the comparison and post feedback concerns and other faces to be compared. We are working on enhancing the comparison to provide a comprehensive comparison of the two products to help the IT Community is finding what fit them best of the two products. Thanks for every one help, as it will reflect for the good of everyone. Enjoy, vmguru007

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.