Windows Smartphone: A Smart Idea or Not?

You might remember when I wrote about my experiences with PDA devices and my eventual conversion to the “PDAs are useful” point of view about two years ago (March 18, 2005, "PDAs: To Buy or Not To Buy," InstantDoc ID 45765). I've continued to use my Dell Axim 50v PDA daily.

To reduce the number of gadgets I carry, many readers have suggested that I switch to a combination cell phone/PDA device that runs Windows Mobile. But I'm put off by the compromise I'd have to make in the phone versus PDA form factor (the need for sleek portability versus having enough keyboard space), the lack of support for Secure Digital (SD) memory, and, of course, the hefty price tag.

However, when I needed a new cell phone recently, I decided to consider a Windows Smartphone. (Although I've used a Research in Motion BlackBerry in the past, I’ve never found the device compelling.) Armed with my basic criteria--that the device be a Windows Smartphone, that it handle email well, and, of course, that it function well as a cell phone--I went to the store. I ended up with a Samsung BlackJack.

Surprisingly, the phone is fairly simple to use because the interface is organized like a Windows device. The software gives me easy access to my Microsoft Exchange and POP email accounts and to the Internet via the Cingular High-Speed Digital Packet Access (HSDPA) network. The document viewer in the software lets me read .doc and .pdf files without having to go to a regular computer. Using a Bluetooth headset with the BlackJack is a simple matter of pairing one of my existing headsets with the device. However, to take full advantage of the BlackJack’s features, which include Windows Media Player and support for microSD storage, I picked up a set of stereo Bluetooth headphones, which let me listen to music and make phone calls hands-free. By using the SD adapter that came with the 2GB microSD card I can easily transfer files between the phone, my notebook, and my PDA. The phone uses Microsoft ActiveSync to connect and synchronize with desktop data, just as any Windows Mobile device does. I haven’t tried setting the BlackJack up with Windows Mobile Device Center for Vista yet, but that’s on the to-do list for next week. The additional email access Windows Mobile Device Center provides means I won’t have to make a special trip to check my email as long as I’m in range of Cingular’s 3G or EDGE networks, which cover most of my travel area.

This Windows Smartphone works well for me. However, other options might function better for you. The key is finding one that fits the way you work.

Tip –

I’ve gotten reports from some users of Microsoft Internet Explorer 7.0 (IE 7) that when they go to the Advanced tab when configuring Internet Options (Tools, Internet Options, Advanced), Settings options are missing. This problem is caused by a missing or corrupted registry subkey at HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Internet Explorer\AdvancedOptions. To fix the problem, take the following steps:

1. Go to Start, All Programs, Accessories, Command Prompt, and open a command prompt window.
2. Enter the command
regsvr32 /n /I /s inetcpl.cpl
3. Close the command prompt window

Discuss this Article 4

dchernic
on Mar 4, 2007
IRelative to the blackberry, I think that their are probably specialized functions that the blackberry devices do better, but I find the Blackjack very usable for email, both web based email and POP mail, as well as Outlook. Syncing public folders can apparently be done using Good Mobile Messagiung, but that would require that your company implement a Good server. I found that OWA is very usable from the Blackjack, especially if I'm in range of the HSDPA network. The HSDPA network was the reason I stayed with Cingular options. Performance around here is significantly better than EVDO.
whc4whc4
on Mar 2, 2007
Smartphones are great, but given the fact that you didn't want to make too many compromises over your PDA, I'm surprised you didn't go for a PocketPC based phone. I've got a Verizon Wireless XV6700 PPC and it is a true convergence device. It runs Windows Mobile 5, has a full size PDA type touch-screen, and has all of the features that my old Dell Axim had PLUS it has a very nice pull-out keyboard that has keys that are three times the size of the keys on a Blackberry. Like all Windows Mobile 5 devices, it supports Direct-Push Exchange email (i.e. over-the-air synchronization with Exchange...Blackberry style.) If all of that isn't enough technology for you, I should also mention that it has a 1.3 Megapixel camera (with flash), it will hold a mini-SD memory card (I use a 2GB card), and it has EVDO (high-speed PCS-based data service), infrared, bluetooth, AND WiFi built-in. While the phone has a list price of $399, you can almost always get it for less than that. I bought mine brand new from Verizon and paid $199 by signing a two year contract.
WoodyC5
on Mar 1, 2007
I am also looking for a smartphone. Does the blackjack email work as well as blackberry? I have a blackberry but I do not like it at all. The only good thing about it is the email functionality that it provides. So I need to find a smartphone that is as good as the blackberry. How does the internet explorer work on the blackjack is it as good as a PDA that has wireless?
flexman
on Mar 1, 2007
I also converted to Mobile 5.0, moving from a Treo 650 to a Cingular 8525. Love everything, except it appears that Direct Push and WM 5.0 don't support synching of Public Folders. We use a companywide Contacts public folder, but there's no way apparently to get it to sync using Direct Push.

Please or Register to post comments.

IT/Dev Connections

Las Vegas
September 30th - October 4th

Paul ThurottYou'll have the opportunity to experience:
• The Microsoft
Technology Roadmap
• Office 365 Implementation
• Hyper-V Optimizing
• Windows 8 Deployment
and much more!

Come See Paul Thurrott & Rod Trent in Person!

Early Registration Now Open

Upcoming Training

Mastering SharePoint 2013: Succeeding, Not Just Surviving

Building on the success of the “Mastering SharePoint 2010” seminars, the presenters have updated the content to cover the latest and greatest SharePoint product: SharePoint 2013. While SharePoint 2013 is relatively new on the marketplace, the presenters have been working with SharePoint 2013 for well over a year, and have implemented it with a number of clients in production environments.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.