Table 1: Comparison of IIS 7.0 Authentication Methods
  Basic
Authentication
Digest
Authentication
NTLM Kerberos Client Certificate–based (SSL/TLS) Forms Authentication
Protocol based on open standard? Yes Yes No Yes Yes No
Relies on Windows accounts? Yes Yes Yes Yes No No
Requires AD accounts? No Yes Yes Yes No No
Supports non-IE browsers? Yes Yes No No Yes Yes
Requires SSL? Yes No No No Yes Yes
IE version requirements All IE versions IE 5.0 or later IE 2.0 or later IE 5.0 or later All IE versions All IE versions
Supports authentication through firewalls and proxies? Yes Yes Only on selected proxies; also works with tunnel connection Only if Kerberos traffic is allowed; also works with tunnel connection Yes Yes
Overall security quality? Weak: Base64 encoded, requires SSL Strong: Based on a challenge-response mechanism; advanced digest authentication (default for IIS 7.0) is the recommended version Strong: Based on a challenge-response mechanism; NTLM v2 is the recommended version Strong: Based on an open standard Strong: Based on asymmetric cryptographic mechanism Strong: If combined with SSL