Data Security in the Cloud: Who's Responsible & How Does It Happen?


Does your company use a cloud service to store sensitive or confidential data? If so, where does the responsibility lie for keeping that data secure? These are a couple of the questions addressed in a new study released by Thales e-Security. The study, titled "Encryption in the Cloud," also focused on data encryption with cloud solutions and where such encryption is applied.

One of the big surprises in the survey data comes from how many companies are using the cloud for sensitive or confidential data: nearly half, 49 percent, of respondents do so currently, and another third said their companies likely would do so within the next two years. With that amount of sensitive corporate data going to the cloud, data security must be a primary concern -- or so you might think.

Another section of the survey, which was conducted by the Ponemon Institute, looked at where companies felt the responsibility fell for keeping safe that data they were sending to the cloud. Here, 44 percent of respondents said they felt the primary responsibility for data security was with the cloud provider, while only 30 percent thought primary responsibility was with the data owner (i.e., the company that's sending sensitive data to the cloud). Another 24 percent thought there should be a shared responsibility.

I would have thought that businesses that had strong concerns for the security of their data would have answered more towards keeping responsibility for themselves, or possibly sharing responsibility -- after all, regardless of where the data is, your company is still the one on the hook if your customers' data gets loose. When you couple that possibility with another finding from the research -- namely, that 63 percent of respondents said they had no idea what security measures cloud providers used to secure the sensitive data entrusted to them -- it begins to look like companies are simply taking an easy solution by sending data to the cloud and washing their hands of responsibility. They're hoping the hammer of data loss won't fall on them.

Richard Moulds, vice president of product management and strategy for Thales e-Security, had another possibility in mind. "It may be the case that the companies that are sending data to the cloud today are the ones that are encrypting it themselves and keeping hold of the keys," he said, "and therefore have a pretty high security posture and feel pretty good about it because they know that they are in control." Key management is, uh, key, according to Moulds, when using encryption: Make sure you're not storing the key with the encrypted data.

"Encryption is a very definitive approach to security," Moulds said. "It's either encrypted or it's not, it's black or white. It's a very binary type of security. I think that's why regulators like it -- it's the reason it's mandated in policies like PCI DSS. Mandating the use of a firewall is a bit wishy-washy because you can have a good or bad firewall. You don't see the use of firewalls or intrusion detection as factors in data breach disclosure law." Of course, when considering a cloud solution, data encryption can be applied at different points: on the customer side before transmission; during transmission; or in the cloud itself.

Regardless of which method (or methods) you choose, Moulds believes it's important for the enterprise to maintain control of the encryption keys. "I can imagine a world where data is shared with the cloud in encrypted form and is selectively decrypted by the enterprise giving out keys on demand to cloud providers or applications in the cloud -- then they can do something with that data. So the data is still, as it lies, protected. It's protected by default, and it's selectively unprotected just to the point of use," Moulds said.

The level of control Moulds envisions is not, perhaps, borne out by the survey data of what businesses are currently doing -- but then, he did say he was imagining. Encryption is clearly useful for protecting data, but James D. Brown, CTO for StillSecure, believes that taking a layered approach to security is best, whether in the cloud or on the local network. Brown also said he felt the job of managing data security should be in the hands of security experts.

"Security really needs to be a 24 by 7 operation," Brown said. "It's not something where you set up a product and leave it sitting in a closet somewhere and check it once in a while. If you do that, chances are you're going to be attacked and compromised and you'll be looking at that information after the fact. It really needs to be monitored 24 by 7, and it needs to be monitored by experts, and it needs to be deployed by experts."

As more companies move important chunks of their business processes and corresponding data to cloud providers, questions about cloud security can only increase. If you're interested in more findings from "Encryption in the Cloud," be sure to download the complete report. And if you're interested in a little extra chilling factor, consider this: This study addresses the data organizations knowingly transfer to cloud sites; it doesn't consider the corporate data your employees might be sending to personal data sharing sites, and the related risks associated with such behavior. That, of course, is a topic for another day.

Follow B. K. Winstead on Twitter at @bkwins
Follow Windows IT Pro on Twitter at @windowsitpro

Discuss this Blog Entry 4

on Aug 14, 2012
Interesting blog on Data Security in the Cloud. Now new Cloud ecosystem Hub which was just launched provides organizations a unified gateway to build, manage and govern their hybrid cloud ecosystem.
on Aug 17, 2012
One provider worth looking at is - they maintain zero-knowledge of customer data, and have a forthcoming enterprise product SpiderOak Blue as well.
on Oct 30, 2012
Cloudlink is an example of an encryption overlay software which allows the enterprise to maintain control of the encryption key(s). This will soon become standard practice in order to be in compliance with HIPAA, PCI, etc...
on Aug 29, 2012
I do not know much about the security mechanics behind cloud computing but I recently crashed my PC and not even Best Buy's Geek Squad could recover my files. I lost everything to include my kids baby pictures. I was very disappointed but went home and started doing some research on the best cloud servers. I found that "MYPCBackup" was very reliable and affordable; I ordered the service for $4.95/ month and was so impressed with the service that I also became an affiliate of the company. This service takes care of that for you by automatically storing all your files securely online using its military-grade security on the most reliable cloud servers in the World. Your files will be completely protected for less than you'd pay for a Value Meal at McDonalds (ha ha ha). Below I have include my unique affiliate link ( ) which will allow you to signup for a free account which has 15MB space, this isn't a lot but it is a start. I hope you all take advantage of this opportunity as I wish I had two weeks ago.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Cloud Computing?

Cloud computing information, news, and tips covering Hyper-V, IaaS, PaaS, private cloud, public cloud, SaaS, security, trends, and more.


B. K. Winstead

B. K. Winstead is a former editor for Windows IT Pro specializing in Exchange Server, messaging, mobility, unified communications, and cloud computing.

Jeff James

Jeff James is a former editor for Windows IT Pro.
Blog Archive

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×