If you haven't yet heard about Microsoft's Unified Communications (UC) strategy,
chances are good that you'll be hearing about it ad nauseam over the
next 6 to 12 months. Steve Ballmer and his crew have made it very clear that
they're ready to take the world of convergence head-on. With apologies to Microsoft
Speech Server, Exchange Server 2007 Unified Messaging (UM)—released late
last year—was Microsoft's first real attempt to enter the IP telephony
market. Exchange UM provides the ability to integrate voicemail, fax, and of
course email into a single mailbox solution. However, Exchange UM still relies
on third-party telephony systems, whether legacy PBX or IP-PBX solutions.
At the same time, the concept of "presence" is causing
quite a stir. Companies such as Microsoft, Cisco, and IBM
are all battling for the rights to own and control the presence engine. What is presence? It's the ability to locate and
identify a person (or group of people) and communicate
with them, regardless of the means of communication (e.g.,
PC, desk phone, cell phone, IM). Microsoft's first attempt at
presence was Microsoft Office Live Communications Server
2005 (LCS 2005). (Exchange 2000 Server IM and LCS 2003
predate LCS 2005 but were crude at best.) However, LCS
wasn't an ideal solution.
With the introduction of Microsoft Office Communications Server (OCS) 2007, Microsoft merges call control (the
ability to route and place a telephone call) and presence
technologies together into a single offering. OCS 2007 Beta
3 was released in March 2007. Since the product's release,
Microsoft has been very proactive in distributing the various deployment and administration guides, as well as providing hands-on training for many of their key partners.
Although I've been through Microsoft's official "Ignite" program for partners,
I wanted to step outside the Microsoft sandbox and install OCS Beta 3 from scratch
in my environment. To test the product's functionality, I needed several puzzle
pieces: Active Directory (AD), Exchange 2007, a member server for OCS, and a
Session Initiation Protocol–Public Switched Telephone Network (SIP-PSTN)
gateway. I used an inexpensive, yet very configurable, gateway device from AudioCodes—the
MP-114 (http://www.audiocodes.com/content.aspx?voip=2823).
Installation
Because AD will contain all of the SIP user information and settings, you need
to extend the schema to accommodate these additional attributes. The schema
extension itself is fairly straightforward, with the same administrative requirements
as Exchange, LCS, and Microsoft Systems Management Server (SMS).
Likewise, OCS setup must be run at
both the forest level and domain level to
prep AD. Microsoft has made this portion
of the setup process almost foolproof by
reducing the number of use-interactive
steps required, as well as preventing you
from being able to initiate a step without
finishing the earlier steps.
If you're familiar with LCS installation,
you'll be happy to know that Microsoft has
simplified the process of installing certificates as well. However, a glitch I stumbled
upon is that if your forest and domain functional levels aren't set for Windows Server
2003, the certificate requests will fail with
very little explanation.
One of the handiest installation features is the verification process, which
lets you verify not only server configuration but also connectivity. I discuss
installation of the other server roles later in the article.
Configuration
For anyone familiar with AD, enabling and configuring OCS users is easy. You
can enable users in bulk or on a user-by-user basis. The minimum setting that
must be completed is the SIP address assignment (commonly, the user's email
address). However, additional settings can be configured, including federation
(presence connectivity with other LCS/OCSenabled companies), public IM connectivity
(Yahoo!, MSN, AOL), and remote user access (the ability to connect to OCS from
outside the firewall).
One of OCS's new features is Enhanced Presence, which you can also configure
on a per-user basis. Enhanced Presence lets you place users into various Presence
Access Levels (Block, Public, Workplace, Team Members, and Personal). Each level,
from left to right, allows more presence data to be presented to contacts. For
example, contacts who are in the Public level can see only Presence State (e.g.,
Online, Busy), Display Name, E-mail Address, Title, and Company. At the other
end of the spectrum, Personal contacts can essentially see all user data stored
in AD for a particular user (e.g., Work Phone, Home Phone). A caveat with Enhanced
Presence is that if you enable it, users must use Microsoft Office Communicator
(MOC) 2007. Older versions (e.g., Windows Live Messenger, MOC 2005) won't be
able to connect.
With relation to OCS itself, most of the configuration is already complete
in this scenario. The only piece that still needs configuration is DNS. OCS,
like LCS, requires the creation of specific SRV records in order for automatic
server detection to function. Within DNS, you must create an "Other New Record,"
setting the Service type to _sipinternaltls, protocol to _tcp, and port number
to 5061 (which represents Transport Layer Security—TLS—encrypted
SIP traffic). After configuration, users won't need to enter a specific OCS
server IP address or Fully Qualified Domain Name (FQDN) address into the MOC
client. This is especially important for users who work both onsite and remotely,
because the two IP addresses will almost certainly vary.
Additional Roles
Microsoft seems to be moving toward a distributed solution model in which a
single product needs to be installed on separate physical servers. Such is the
case in Exchange 2007, Microsoft System Center Operations Manager 2007, and
now OCS 2007. What this requirement actually means depends on the size of your
implementation. Roles can be consolidated onto one piece of hardware, but for
larger organizations that will be taxing the resources on an OCS server, additional
physical hardware is needed. The two roles that carry over from LCS 2005 are
Access Proxy and Director.
The Access Proxy role lets you enable remote connectivity, federation, and
public IM connectivity. Although this role is fairly straightforward, additional
network planning is necessary because it resides in a demilitarized zone (DMZ).
The Director role is used to route traffic to the proper OCS pool (OCS servers),
as well as act as a middleman between the Access Proxy role and the front-end
OCS servers. A compromised Access Proxy role can't bring down AD or the OCS
front-end servers, because the Director role would take the brunt of any Denial
of Service (DoS) attack. Installing the Director role is simple.
OCS 2007 also includes four new roles. These roles are telephony enablement
(Mediation Server), on-premise conferencing (Microsoft Office Live Meeting),
compliance (Archiving Server), and remote telephony (Edge Server).
Telephony configuration. Telephony is particularly interesting
to me because of what my company does, so I've spent quite a bit of time working
with OCS's telephony features. Installing and configuring OCS's Mediation Server
role is far simpler than installing some of the more traditional (if we can
use that word yet) VoIP vendor solutions. Because AD already contains much of
the necessary user information, the only areas you need to focus on are call
routing and rules. Setting rules can be a bit confusing if you don't have any
experience writing regular expressions. Figure
1 shows an example. The Help files are almost nonexistent in OCS Beta 3.
However, searching the Web can be useful.
After you've written your rules (and configured your SIP gateway), you can
begin testing the OCS softphone (which is the MOC 2007 application) connectivity
to the outside world. In my lab, I used an AudioCodes MP-114 device (with a
plain old telephone), as well as an SIP trunk to my Cisco CallManager 5 server.
If you don't have access to such equipment, you can use MOC, which also functions
as a softphone, to make MOC-to-MOC calls as if they were telephony calls. This
process effectively eliminates the need for a traditional handset in order to
place a phone call. Microsoft recently announced that their handset line is
in full production via several manufacturing partners (http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2007/may07/05-13newgenwork
phonespr.mspx), which will present some interesting solutions as well.
Something that I found perplexing, at least in the beta version of OCS, is
that only one PSTN gateway is allowed per Mediation Server role. Depending on
the size of the environment, it's not unreasonable to assume that a company
might have one gateway supporting its T1 links and another gateway supporting
PSTN, or possibly a split load for redundancy. We can only hope that this deficiency
is addressed before release.
On a similar note, although OCS's Exchange 2007 UM tie-in appears to be pretty
tight, some of the steps for integrating the two aren't as seamless as you'd
expect. For instance, you must run several command-line scripts, as well as
stop and start several services, for OCS and Exchange 2007 UM to communicate
and interoperate.
Conferencing. For many years now, Microsoft has offered hosted
Live Meeting services via the Web. With the introduction of OCS 2007, Microsoft
brings that same functionality on-premise. OCS 2007 lets you provide ad-hoc
escalation of conferences (e.g., via IM) for internal and federated contacts,
as well as scheduled Live Meeting conferences for "trusted" and anonymous contacts.
Thus, many of the meeting events that you previously outsourced to Microsoft
or other companies (e.g., WebEx) can now be maintained inside your network.
In addition, an Outlook plugin lets you use Outlook's familiar scheduling interface
to set up conferences.
The Live Meeting role's configuration is straightforward and mostly focused
on meeting policies—particularly who is allowed to participate. The Live
Meeting user plug-ins are hands-off, requiring only the basic user information
(sign-in name, service URL, and credentials), as well as a complete restart
of Outlook. OCS 2007's on-premise conferencing services will be a cost-effective,
user-friendly solution for companies. Oddly enough, OCS 2007 is becoming available
at the same time that Cisco is moving in the other direction— from
on-premise (Cisco MeetingPlace) to offpremise (with the acquisition of WebEx).
Only time will tell which method end users prefer, or whether both methods will
simply coexist.
Compliance. One of the major reasons for implementing an in-house
presence solution is to keep confidential company information off the public
wire. However, because you can configure OCS for federation and public IM connectivity,
this information can be leaked. Although actually preventing users from revealing
this type of information is difficult, you can easily record and audit communications
that initiated from OCS.
One of the downsides of archiving for many companies is that to implement archiving,
you typically need another server, as well as another instance of Microsoft
SQL Server. However, installing the archiving service is a straightforward process.
The last step in configuration is simply associating the Archiving Server role
with a front-end server. Again, stopping and restarting OCS services on the
front-end servers is a bit disruptive but is necessary to properly configure
the archiving server.
Viewing archived OCS data is no easy feat for a SQL Server novice. The only
way I could find to view an archived conversation was through SQL Server Management
Studio (SSMS)—and only then because of some documentation that Microsoft
provided to me.
A new OCS feature, Call Detail Record (CDR), includes some slick trending and
analysis reports that take advantage of Excel 2007's new conditional formatting
feature. CDR isn't new to telephony—this feature is crucial to a telephony
system's reliability and functionality. In addition to standard CDR information
(e.g., missed calls, call duration), OCS's CDR reports provide several key pieces
of information, including tracking of:
• application sharing sessions
• A/V sessions
• file transfer sessions
• length of IM sessions
• number of IM sessions
• number of IM messages
• number of IM users
• remote access sessions
Remote telephony. In LCS 2005, if you want to work remotely and
use A/V, data sharing, or remote access, you must first connect through your
VPN. This requirement is necessary because these features are intended to be
point-to-point, and they can't be proxied via the LCS 2005 Access Proxy. Because
public IM services already provided these functions, improving upon this area
was important when Microsoft replaced LCS 2005 with OCS 2007. However,
you still need yet another edge server. Whether the Edge Server role can
(or will) coexist with LCS 2005's Access Proxy server role is yet to be determined—but
it must if you want to provide Live Meeting, A/V, or telephony support for remote
users.
If connectivity "at the edge" works as intended, the Edge Server role will
be a major victory for Microsoft. One area that will become clear over time
is how the quality of a call that's routed through the Internet via the edge
server is affected, especially when multiple users are hitting the gateway at
once. According to Microsoft, a high-quality two-way (dual stream) call requires
approximately 80Kbps of bandwidth. Multiply that by 20 simultaneous calls, and
you could have some congestion on your Internet pipe.
A Force to Be Reckoned With
When Microsoft releases it, OCS 2007 will be a force to be reckoned with. The
previous LCS presence capabilities have been greatly improved, and the voice
capabilities have a lot of promise. Although certain features still need improvement
from the beta version (mainly related to administration and scalability), OCS
2007's one-stop-shopping approach to presence, collaboration, voice, video,
and conferencing will make the product more of a "need" than a "want." With
OCS 2007, Microsoft deftly reigns in the current silos of communication, putting
the rest of the UC world on notice.
| Summary
Microsoft office communications server 2007 beta 3
PROS: Easy setup and installation; improved presence capabilities
over LCS 2005
CONS: Administration and scalability features need improvement
before release to manufacturing (RTM)
RECOMMENDATION: OCS 2007's combined presence, collaboration, voice,
video, and conferencing features make it a one-stop UC solution.
CONTACT: Microsoft • http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/communicationsserver/default.aspx |