Taking Surface to Work

After last week’s commentary -- "Surface with Windows RT is No PC Replacement" -- I received the type of feedback I used to get from Linux users (when there were any) and still get from Apple fanatics. That is, many people were not pleased.

This is interesting to me on a number of levels, and although I’ll spare you my ruminations on the rise of a long-dead (or at least quiet) class of Windows enthusiasts and fanboys, I think it does point to a healthy backlash against years of Apple abusing Microsoft in the consumer space. Say what you will about these companies, but there is clearly a group of Microsoft users who need Surface, and less specifically Windows RT and Windows 8, to succeed.

Sadly, my critical examination of Surface with Windows RT was frequently misunderstood. I have a responsibility as a reviewer to be honest about any and all products that I use, and my Surface piece reflects what an incomplete and frustrating experience this particular device really is. But if you’ve been following along on the SuperSite for Windows, you know that I’m writing a series of tips and other articles about Surface, aimed at helping people overcome these frustrations. Of which there are many.

But enough of that. The Surface is what it is, and regardless of my opinion of the thing, it’s pretty clear that millions of people have purchased the devices and many more will do so in the weeks and months ahead, and that many of them intend to bring it to work. There, as with all things Surface, the picture is pretty good now. But it’s going to get a lot better.

Surface, of course, usually comes with a keyboard cover of some kind and I frankly have a hard time imagining almost anyone using this device without a cover. Although I’m a pretty heavy typist, I realize that most people don’t spend their days tapping away, and although this sounds counter-intuitive, I actually think the thinner, lighter, and less-expensive Touch Cover makes more sense for most people than does the Type Cover. Check out "Microsoft Surface: Touch Cover vs. Type Cover" for more on that one.

Surface, as you might know, comes with a consumer version of Office 2013 that isn’t licensed for commercial (i.e., work) use. However, as Ed Bott over at ZDNet explains in "How much do you have to pay to use Office 2013 RT for work?," you can legally license Office RT for work, assuming you know the trick. He’ll tell you how.

Surface comes with the same desktop-based Remote Desktop Connection (RDC) you know and love from Windows 7 and Windows 8, and it works the same way, allowing you to access remote PCs and servers through RDP. (There’s a Metro version too, if you’re all in on the new stuff.) It’s also compatible with RemoteApp, meaning that you can stream individual apps from servers to the Windows RT desktop, just as you do with normal Windows versions. So that’s all good.

For now, Surface can be managed only using Exchange ActiveSync (EAS). That is, it can’t connect to a domain and be managed with Group Policy. EAS is actually pretty good: You can configure PIN and password policies, do remote wipe, and so on. But if you’re familiar with the granularity of Group Policy, you know you can do a lot more to lock down true Windows clients. And although Windows RT (and thus Surface) can’t partake in that, change is coming.

Soon, Microsoft will ship a revision to its Windows Intune cloud-based PC and device management service. And although the firm hasn’t talked too much about this update, it will include Microsoft’s implementation of the Open Management Interface (OMI), which, put simply, offers more granular management capabilities than does EAS. This will make Surface (and all RT devices) far more manageable than other mobile devices based on Android or iOS. (Yes, Windows Phone 8 will use this management infrastructure, too.)

I can’t say much about OMI yet, but I’ll note that it makes a ton of sense to use a cloud-based service to manage devices that are never going to be connecting to your on-premises infrastructure anyway. It makes so much sense that my understanding is that this capability will never, in fact, be added to System Center. Instead, I believe that System Center licensees will get -- free or inexpensively -- the right to use Intune for this purpose, too.

Will we soon see people toting Surface tablets around instead of Apple’s trendy iPad? I’m pretty sure we’re going to see a mix, and although the Surface might never overtake the iPad, I have to say I like the sign of life that emerged in the wake of last week’s commentary. And although I’m not the overt fan of this device that many of you appear to be, we can all agree on this : It’s going to be getting a lot better, and soon.

Discuss this Article 7

ziggy2692
on Nov 9, 2012
WOW, Everyone Chill out. There is nothing worse than a dishonest journalist. Love or dislike what he says, at least he reviews the Surface truthfully crafted with no bias. I love the Surface, but there are some obvious shortcomings that I hope to be resolved soon. That said I dont agree with Paul all of the time, but the man is nothing but honest and should be applauded for that.
stipman
on Nov 6, 2012
Surface RT was never designed to be a replacement for PC's. It's designed to compete with the other tablets out there. The Surface PRO is targeted at replacing PC's...but you already knew that. I do appreciate your honest review of the product but I find your title poorly selected.
asoyemi
on Nov 6, 2012
You and your article are very cute, yes, I use the word very cute. You are one of those that have trashed Win8 as a whole, but you are using this article to soften up some so that later when Win8 success starts you can argue that you knew it was coming. Yeah, Right! Sorry my man, I am not buying it, try again.
Abasi
on Nov 6, 2012
I was really hoping that you would explain how Surface devices can be managed through system center or something instead of inventing facts like "millions of people have purchased the devices" comment which would make Surface newsworthy on a level of Apple's sales. But no one has heard a peep about Windows 8/Surface/RT since I went to the launch event. The salespeople at the Surface Kiosks are making the iPad look really good since its clear that their training was a rush job or it could be that the product itself is. Let's not talk about "Taking Surface to work" until someone ACTUALLY brings one into the office .... #crickets
pthurrott
on Nov 6, 2012
Thanks, Abasi, sort of. I'm actually not able to discuss the coming management infrastructure more than I have here. There will be more info about this soon, however. Sorry I can't hear the crickets over all the excitement around Surface. stipman: Please don't tell me what Surface was designed as. It is a PC, or a PC replacement, for many people, just as an iPad is. My point was only that it is not a full-fledged Windows PC and thus not a reasonable alternative if you need the full power of Windows 8. That gap will narrow over time. dcpking ... This article IS an op-ed. asoyemi. You're cute too. I don't recall ever trashing Windows 8 "as a whole," but let me re-read my massive 8-part Windows 8 review to make sure ... Nope. Didn't do that. Sorry.
ddeen
on Nov 12, 2012
Microsoft may be selling millions of the Surface RTs now, but as soon as the Windows 8 Surface releases next year, the sales of the RT version will dry up to nothing. Surface 8 will have none of the software limitations of the Surface RT and will be a much better fit for almost everyone. We know Surface 8 will be priced higher but I think the buyer who is deciding whether to buy Surface RT at a discount or forking over a bit more money for something that they can actually use without all the RT restrictions, will chose the Surface 8 most of the time. There is just no downside that I can see to the Surface 8 other than the higher price, and as we have seen with the tremendous sales of the iPad, consumers are willing to pay more money for a better product.
dcpking
on Nov 6, 2012
Just a few things you might like to think about while fiddling with your Win8 display melange: 1. There are lots of Linux users - in fact, chances are that you're one of them. For example, many Windows servers sit in virtuality on a Linux base, Dell servers actually run Linux internally, even though you don't see it, and Google and Facebook run on Linux. Oh yes, and do you have an Android phone? If so, then you're a Linux user :) 2. You posit that there is clearly a class of Windows users who need Surface to succeed. You give no reason for this, however, and also never define the class of Windows users who will otherwise so clearly (in your eyes) become failures! 3. You state that "millions of people have purchased the devices". Your source? In summary, a reasonable article with some rather large flaws that detract from it's overall quality. It would be nice if you would edit it to make it a little less of an op-ed and more of a technical article, given the basic nature of this publication.

Please or Register to post comments.

Upcoming Training

Mastering System Center 2012

During over 6 hours of training you can join John Savill from your computer as he will walk you through the key components and capabilities of System Center 2012, what’s involved in using the components, and the benefit they can bring to your environment.

Register Now

Current Issue

May 2013 - The NameTranslate object is useful when you need to translate Active Directory object names between different formats, but it's awkward to use from PowerShell. Here's a PowerShell script that eliminates the awkwardness.

CURRENT ISSUE / ARCHIVE / SUBSCRIBE

Windows Forums

Get answers to questions, share tips, and engage with the Windows Community in our Forums.