Windows IT Pro is the leading independent community for IT professionals deploying Microsoft Windows server and client applications and technologies.
  
  
  Advanced Search 


July 2006

The Missing Link in Windows’ Group Hierarchy

RSS
Subscribe to Windows IT Pro | See More Active Directory (AD) Articles Here | Reprints | Or get the Monthly Online Pass—only $5.95 a month!

There are many administrative groups in a Windows network. Every Windows NT-based machine has an Administrators group (i.e., the SAM) in its local user database to manage that computer. In addition, there are administrative groups in the domain database (i.e., the Active Directory—AD—database) to manage the domain. These groups include the Administrators, Domain Admins, and Enterprise Admins groups. When a Windows NT-based computer group joins an AD domain, the Domain Admins group is added to the local Administrators group of that machine. Hence, the members of the Domain Admins group gain the necessary rights on that machine.

Domain Admins group members have the rights to manage all the computers in a domain, including domain controllers (DCs) and client computers. The Administrators group in the AD database has the rights to manage DCs. The Enterprise Admins group has some forestwide rights. What's missing is a group that can't manage DCs and other crucial servers but can manage the rest of the computers.

At our company, we frequently need a group to manage client computers but not crucial servers. Although there is no such built-in group, a good systems engineer can create one. We found two ways to do so. To illustrate these approaches, let's say we want to create a group that contains technicians who will be responsible for managing client computers but not crucial servers.

The first approach is to create group that has an appropriate name such as Technicians and add the technicians to it. After you create this group, you need to create an organizational unit (OU) that contains the client computers. In that OU, you need to restrict the membership of the Administrators group by using the Restricted Groups policy. The Administrators group should contain only the Technicians group and the local administrator account. By doing so, the members of the Technicians group become the administrators of the client computers.

Although this approach works, it has a drawback. An AD quota prevents ordinary users from adding more than 10 computer accounts to the domain. The members of the technicians group are ordinary users, except that they're the administrators of the client computers. Thus, the technicians can't add more than 10 computer accounts to the domain.

The second approach isn't intuitive, but it avoids the AD quota problem. You add the technicians to the Domain Admins group, then remove Domain Admins group from the Administrators group in AD and from the Administrators group of every crucial server. By doing so, the technicians become the administrators of only the client computers. The technicians can add any number of computer accounts to the domain because they belong to the Domain Admins group.

Both of these approaches work. The approach that works best for you will depend on your environment.

—Murat Yildirimoglu and Ugur Duman

End of Article



Reader Comments
I would like to point out that users that are granted the Create Computer Objects permission on the Active Directory container where the computers reside are not restricted to the 10 computer limit. Option 1, as described in this article, is a much better method for creating a group to manage the computers within your AD structure and not grant them Domain Admin privilages. Creating the restricted group and then delegating the proper authority over the OU that contains your computer accounts will work just fine without any drawbacks.

Daniel July 13, 2006 (Article Rating: )


Putting the users in Domain Admins group, then removing permissions from the Domain Admins group is NOT a good solution in my opinion. What do you do with the users that NEED full Domain Admins rights? Create a new group for them and assign that new group all the rights they need? You might as well have done that in the first place when creating the group to manage the client computers...

The Delegation of Authority option was given to you for a reason...use it.

zixster August 07, 2006 (Article Rating: )


dear zixster,

Quotas and permissions are two different animals. Take the file permissions and disk quota for example. You can have NTFS write permission on a certain disk but if there is a disk quota restricting the disk usage to only 100 MB, you can create files only up to 100 MB. Permissions do not help us overcome the quota restrictions.

Murat Yildirimoglu

muraty September 06, 2006 (Article Rating: )


You must be a registered user or online subscriber to comment on this article. Please log on before posting a comment. Are you a new visitor? Register now




Top Viewed ArticlesView all articles
Command Prompt Tricks

One reader shares his tip for setting up the command prompt to reflect a remote path. ...

WinInfo Short Takes: Week of November 9, 2009

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news, including some more Windows 7 sales momentum, some Sophos stupidity, Microsoft's cloud computing self-loathing, more whining from the browser makers, Zoho's "Fake Office," and much, much more ...

Understanding File-Size Limits on NTFS and FAT

A general confusion about files sizes on FAT seems to stem from FAT32's file-size limit of 4GB and partition-size limit of 2TB. ...


Active Directory (AD) Whitepapers Meeting Compliance Objectives in SharePoint

Email Controls and Regulatory Compliance

Related Events WinConnections and Microsoft® Exchange Connections

Troubleshooting Active Directory

Deep Dive into Windows Server 2008 R2 presented by John Savill

Check out our list of Free Email Newsletters!

Active Directory (AD) eBooks The Essentials Series: Active Directory 2008 Operations

Keeping Your Business Safe from Attack: Monitoring and Managing Your Network Security

Windows 2003: Active Directory Administration Essentials

Related Active Directory (AD) Resources Introducing Left-Brain.com, the online IT bookstore
Looking for books, CDs, toolkits, eBooks? Prime your mind at Left-Brain.com

Discover Windows IT Pro eLearning Series!
Clear & detailed technical information and helpful how-to's, all in our trademark no-nonsense format


Windows IT Pro Home Register FAQ for Windows WinInfo News
Europe Edition About Us Contact Us/Customer Service Media Kit Affiliates / Licensing  
SQL Server Magazine Office & SharePoint Pro DevProConnections IT Job Hound
Left-Brain.com Technology Resource Directory asp.netPRO ITTV Windows SuperSite 
 
 Windows IT Pro is a Division of Penton Media Inc.
 © 2009 Penton Media, Inc. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement