Windows IT Pro is the leading independent community for IT professionals deploying Microsoft Windows server and client applications and technologies.
  
  
  Advanced Search 


March 27, 2008

The Advantage of Using an RODC Rather Than a DC


RSS
View this exclusive article with VIP access -- click here to join |
See More Active Directory (AD) Articles Here | Reprints | Or sign up for our VIP Monthly Pass!
Main Article    Access Denied
Q: Will the new read-only domain controller (RODC) feature in Windows Server 2008 address the risks of domain controllers (DCs) that are placed at remote sites, such as branch offices, that aren’t as physically secure as the corporate data center?

A: You can now configure DCs as RODCs in Server 2008, which will address some, but not all, the risks. RODCs receive one-way replication from other DCs, thereby maintaining a local replica of the Active Directory (AD) domain. RODCs will fill the need to have a replica of AD locally at branch offices for fault tolerance, conservation of bandwidth, and performance reasons. Because the DC is read-only, an attacker that takes over the DC can’t change group memberships or user accounts in such a way that they replicate back to DCs at the data center and beyond. However, RODCs don’t address every risk. Someone very skilled or equipped with malicious programs created by a skilled programmer still might be able to exploit physical access, take over the RODC, and succeed in making the DC authenticate them to other computers on the network as an administrator or other privileged user. Although an attacker won’t be able to exploit the RODC to permanently change anything in AD, he could temporarily exploit the RODC to break into other computers in the domain or forest. Nevertheless, RODCs are a very important step in the right direction. . . .


Already a VIP member?
Please log on to view the full article

Why become a VIP member?

VIP-only online access
VIP CD delivered twice a year: offline access to the entire Windows IT Pro article library
Monthly issue of your choice of Windows IT Pro or SQL Server Magazine

Subscribe Now
Reader Comments
Excellent Article

sharath_hp2003@yahoo.com April 17, 2008 (Article Rating: )


Thanks for taking the time to give us your feedback. Glad you found this article helpful!

AnneG_editor May 02, 2008 (Article Rating: )


Note that the statement regarding attacking an RODC is misleading as it doesn't account for all the extra measures that were built into RODC to ensure that attacks that happen within a site don't have any reach to resources elsewhere. Note that a site is typically a branch site that only contains resources from a single domain (even in a multi-domain deployment). The main measures are the enhancements in the Kerberos authentication logic, that are ignored by the author. The fact is that RODCs don't share the same krbtgt account and password as writeable DCs do - instead every RODC has its own krbtgt account. So when a computer or user that has been authenticated by an RODC wants to access a resources outside of the scope of that RODC (for example a resource in a different site), it will - as always - have to request a Kerberos service ticket for that resource. Since the RODC can't generate this, the request is forwarded to a writeable DC, which strips away the whole PAC of the Kerberos ticket coming from the RODC (as it could include a forged group membership) and regenerates it based on its own AD data.

Se even if a site contained resources from multiple domains (let's say DOM1 and DOM2), a successful attack of RODC of DOM1 would only allow to elevate privileges on computers in THAT site from THAT domain - i.e. from DOM1. For example, a skilled attacker might be able to add himself to an AD group on the RODC that grants access to DOM1 computers in that site. However, a computer from DOM2 does not trust the RODC of DOM1 and thus would not be vulnerable to this attack. Instead - to receive a service ticket for the resource from DOM2 (even if it's in the same site), the RODC of DOM1 would forward the request of the kerb service ticket to a hub-DC, which would re-generate the kerberos ticket and then follow the trust path to a DC from DOM2.

So while an attacked RODC doesn't save you from every harm, it saves you from much more than the author suggests.

winntmag@grillenmeier.de October 09, 2008 (Article Rating: )


You must be a registered user or online subscriber to comment on this article. Please log on before posting a comment. Are you a new visitor? Register now




Top Viewed ArticlesView all articles
Command Prompt Tricks

One reader shares his tip for setting up the command prompt to reflect a remote path. ...

WinInfo Short Takes: Week of November 23, 2009

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news, including some post-PDC some soul searching, a Google Chrome OS announcement and a Microsoft response, Windows 7 off to a supposedly strong start, the Jonas Brothers and Xbox 360, and so much more ...

2009 Windows IT Pro Editors' Best and Community Choice Awards

Picking a favorite product from an impressive crowd of competitive offerings is never an easy task, and such was the case with our Editors' Best and Community Choice awards this year. ...


Active Directory (AD) Whitepapers Meeting Compliance Objectives in SharePoint

Email Controls and Regulatory Compliance

Solving Desktop Management Challenges in Education

Related Events Troubleshooting Active Directory

Deep Dive into Windows Server 2008 R2 presented by John Savill

Getting ready for Windows 7, eLearning series with Mark Minasi

Check out our list of Free Email Newsletters!

Active Directory (AD) eBooks The Essentials Series: Active Directory 2008 Operations

Keeping Your Business Safe from Attack: Monitoring and Managing Your Network Security

Windows 2003: Active Directory Administration Essentials

Related Active Directory (AD) Resources Introducing Left-Brain.com, the online IT bookstore
Looking for books, CDs, toolkits, eBooks? Prime your mind at Left-Brain.com

Discover Windows IT Pro eLearning Series!
Clear & detailed technical information and helpful how-to's, all in our trademark no-nonsense format


Windows IT Pro Home Register FAQ for Windows WinInfo News
Europe Edition About Us Contact Us/Customer Service Media Kit Affiliates / Licensing  
SQL Server Magazine Office & SharePoint Pro DevProConnections IT Job Hound
Left-Brain.com Technology Resource Directory asp.netPRO ITTV Windows SuperSite 
 
 Windows IT Pro is a Division of Penton Media Inc.
 © 2009 Penton Media, Inc. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement