Windows IT Pro is the leading independent community for IT professionals deploying Microsoft Windows server and client applications and technologies.
  
  
  Advanced Search 


November 22, 2006

WinInfo Short Takes: Thanksgiving 2006 Special Edition

RSS
Subscribe to Windows IT Pro | See More News and Analysis Articles Here | Reprints | Or get the Monthly Online Pass—only $5.95 a month!

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news, including Thanksgiving (of course), Zune silliness, the non-existent Office 2007 kill switch, the non-existent Fresno, Office 2007 UI licensing, a threatened Novell and Microsoft pact, and much more...

WinInfo Blog

Short Takes

- Microsoft: Sorry, Mary, There's No Office "Kill Switch"
- Microsoft: No Such Thing as Fresno
- Microsoft Will License Office 2007 UI for Free
- Not News: Microsoft Still Working on Vista, or More Correctly,
Microsoft Partners Still Working on Vista Drivers
- Microsoft/Novell Pact Already in Tatters
- US: Windows Vista Is in Compliance with Antitrust Accord
- Rumor Debunking: No "Gears of War" for PC
- Microsoft Didn't Create Zune (Obviously), But--and this Is the
Important Bit--the Company IS Responsible for It
- Surprise: Dell Profits Are Up
- Google Share Price Hits $500
- Happy Thanksgiving

==== WinInfo Blog ====

by Paul Thurrott, thurrott@windowsitpro.com

There's something wonderful about Thanksgiving, despite its roots in Puritan America. The Puritans were so pious that they considered forks a luxury, and the fact that a tradition they (sort of) started is flourishing in the modern world is somewhat incredible. That the Thanksgiving holiday has made it to this point with minimal crass commercialization is even more incredible: Today, Thanksgiving is still just about getting together with family and enjoying a fine meal. Oh, and watching some football. It's exactly what the Puritans envisioned, I'm sure.

Attention Zune users: How many of you have actually found another Zune owner in the wild and shared music or photos wirelessly? Anyone? Bueller? I'm just kidding, of course. You'd have better luck catching a coelacanth in Boston Harbor than you would finding someone with a Zune.

The Windows Weekly podcast should be back in action this week, despite the holiday. We're going to record Friday's show this evening, if possible.

==== Short Takes ====

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news
by Paul Thurrott, thurrott@windowsitpro.com

Microsoft: Sorry, Mary, There's No Office "Kill Switch"

Last week, ZDNet blogger Mary Jo Foley claimed that Microsoft had added a "kill switch" to the Microsoft Office 2007 system that would force the product into a reduced-functionality mode if Microsoft detected that the product was pirated. Not true, Microsoft says. The version of Office Genuine Advantage (OGA) included with Office 2007 doesn't support this functionality at all--a fact that the software maker had previously disclosed.

Microsoft: No Such Thing as Fresno

Several of my friends at Microsoft contacted me this week to tell me that the End User License Agreement (EULA)-less Longhorn Server appliance product I mentioned last week isn't happening. And that's a shame, because the device--supposedly code-named Fresno--seemed like a great idea. What is happening is a new mid-sized-business server, code-named Centro, and a Windows Server 2003 Release 2 (R2)-based home server--the latter of which we've been anticipating for some time now. Stay tuned.

Microsoft Will License Office 2007 UI for Free

This is fun: Microsoft said this week that it will license its innovative new Office 2007 UI--which uses tabs and ribbons instead of old-school menus and toolbars--to any interested parties for free. The license will let anyone build applications that look and work like Office 2007--a capability that the company's partners have repeatedly requested. Given that Microsoft spent hundreds of millions of dollars developing the so-called RibbonX UI, you have to love the price. Plus, it's a cool UI.

Not News: Microsoft Still Working on Vista, or More Correctly, Microsoft Partners Still Working on Vista Drivers

Several reports have surfaced this week describing how Microsoft is still working on Windows Vista in the months leading up to its January 30, 2007, launch. That's not completely true, however. What's really happening is that Microsoft's hardware partners are working on getting Vista-compatible drivers ready for the launch, and these drivers will be made available to Vista customers via Windows Update. The only Vista-based work Microsoft is actively doing right now is on Windows Ultimate Extras, those Microsoft Plus!-like applications and services the company will offer to Vista Ultimate users beginning in January.

Microsoft/Novell Pact Already in Tatters

Why can't we just get along? Oh, right, one of us is a drooling, monopolistic superpower and the other is a New Age hippy convinced that we can all make money by giving away software. This week, it became clear that the Microsoft/Novell pact was made with a lot of false assumptions on both sides, apparently, with Microsoft claiming that Novell must pay it $40 million to cover Linux violations of Microsoft's intellectual property. Meanwhile, Novell says it never agreed that Linux violates Microsoft's intellectual property. But it gets worse: The Free Software Foundation (FSF), which owns the Linux license, says that Microsoft should pledge not to sue all Linux users over this problem; otherwise, Linux companies shouldn't work with Microsoft. The problem is that the Microsoft/Novell pact violates the GNU General Public License (GPL) under which Linux is licensed. "We have agreed to disagree," a Microsoft representative said. You know, wars start over disagreements such as this one.

US: Windows Vista Is in Compliance with Antitrust Accord

This week, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a report with the US District Court in Washington, DC this week, stating that Microsoft appears to have met its antitrust settlement commitments with Vista and Internet Explorer (IE) 7.0. "Microsoft [has] addressed all outstanding middleware-related bug issues prior to Vista being released to manufacturing," the report notes. If only Microsoft could be this successful with the European Union (EU).

Rumor Debunking: No "Gears of War" for PC

Rabid video game fans quickly made the recently released "Gears of War" the fastest-selling Xbox 360 game ever, with sales of the Xbox 360-specific shooter barely missing the historic mark that "Halo 2" set two years ago. But when a Microsoft promotional image of a retail end cap for its Games for Windows initiative showed a copy of "Gears of War" on the shelves, the excitement really broke out: Microsoft was going to bring "Gears of War" to the PC! There's just one problem: It ain't happening. "This DOES NOT indicate a confirmation that 'Gears of Wars' will be a Games for Windows title--it was a concept image created by a concept artist, nothing more," a Microsoft spokesperson said. "We're incredibly excited about the success of 'Gears of War' on Xbox 360, but we have nothing further to announce about 'Gears of War' or any other platforms it might come to, at this time."

Microsoft Didn't Create Zune (Obviously), But--and this Is the Important Bit--the Company IS Responsible for It

I've been pretty critical of Microsoft's Zune because the device is a half-hearted attempt at wresting control away from Apple's iPod at a time when Microsoft really needs a home run. But there's a bizarre argument making the rounds that in this case, criticism of Microsoft is unfounded because Microsoft didn't even make the Zune: The device is essentially a Toshiba gigabeat wrapped with a branding message that a marketing company in California created. And although I'm sure we're all hugely surprised that there isn't an iota of innovative work in a Microsoft product, I'd like to bring everyone back to one crucial point: It doesn't matter which company manufactured it, designed it, or came up with the marketing. Microsoft is selling this device to you, its customers, and the device is therefore Microsoft's responsibility. Any success or failure with the Zune rests in the hands of the people who hatched the half-baked plot. This is hubris at its most obvious: Sell it and they will come. But buy it ... and you are dumb.

Surprise: Dell Profits Are Up

This week, Dell reported a higher-than-expected profit for its fiscal third quarter, somewhat blunting a recent bout of problems at the company. Dell says its new strategy of selling more profitable PCs--rather than engaging in an all-out pricing war--appears to be working, and the company claims to have also made dramatic customer service improvements. Dell's net income rose 12 percent year-to-year to $677 million on revenues of $14.4 billion. Dell's earnings results were delayed because of an ongoing formal Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investigation. So Dell's troubles aren't necessarily over yet.

Google Share Price Hits $500

From the "capitalism can be stupid" files, we bring you the latest bit of Googlemania: This week, Google's shares actually crossed the $500 mark, increasing the company's market capitalization to $155 billion. That means that Google--which earns virtually all its money from online advertising--is worth four times as much money, at least on paper, as Yahoo!, its closest competitor. Google is now the 15th largest company in the world, and if I understand things correctly, Google cofounders Larry Page and Sergey Brin can now be considered replacements for Colonel Sanders in "The Star Chamber." I just want to make sure this is perfectly clear: These guys sell thumbnail-sized text ad placements on Web sites. That's what they do.

Happy Thanksgiving

Because of the Thanksgiving holiday here in the United States, we won't be publishing the WinInfo Daily Update newsletter again until Monday, November 27, 2006. However, if anything important happens before then, I'll be available to post to the Web site. Enjoy the long weekend. --Paul

End of Article



Reader Comments
"Microsoft Licensing Office 2007 UI for Free"

Well boy howdy! I'm suprised at this. Component makers like Infragistics.com use this as a selling point to have your applications look like Outlook/Office.

anonymous November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"This license will let anyone build applications that look and work like Office 2007, a request the company has gotten repeatedly from partners."

Not so fast there, pardner.

It's not for "anyone". Microsoft says: "...if you are building a program which directly competes with Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, or Access (the Microsoft applications with the new UI), you can't obtain the royalty-free license."

Also, you have to accept their licensing terms BEFORE you get the usage guidelines--which you must follow to the letter in order to stay compliant.

Microsoft uses the term "virtually anyone". Even that's being generous, IMHO.

-----

"And while I'm sure we're all hugely surprising [sic] that there isn't an iota of innovative work in a Microsoft product..."

I know I, for one, am hugely surprised. I'm shocked to hear that "The device is essentially a Toshiba GigaBeat wrapped with a branding message that was created by a marketing company in California", because I thought Microsoft worked on this thing for a year!

It's been five years since the iPod was introduced. If this is the best that Microsoft and its partners can come up with, it's really sad.

-----

"I just want to make sure this is perfectly clear. These guys sell thumbnail-sized text ad placements. On Web sites. That's what they do."

Jealous much? ;-)

Have a great Thanksgiving.

lotsamystuff November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


@lotsamystuff
"It's not for "anyone". Microsoft says: "...if you are building a program which directly competes with Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, or Access (the Microsoft applications with the new UI), you can't obtain the royalty-free license."

No kidding. That's what the majority, if not all, of the component makers licensing terms are. Besides, how many people are actually creating a Word/Outlook/Powerpoint/Excel program. Its pointless if your trying to make money off of it.

anonymous November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


@Microsoft Licensing Office 2007 UI for Free:
Here's hoping the folks at OpenOffice.org take advantage of Microsoft's free, superior UI.

@Not News-Vista Drivers:
Not just Microsoft partners, they have to code their own drivers for the Zune!


@Microsoft/Novell Pact Already in Tatters:
Show us the non-compliant parts, MS. Otherwise, you're just SCO.


@US: Windows Vista is in Compliance with Antitrust Accord:
The last I saw, Windows Vista has IE7 bundled with it. And for most consumers, they'd have to open IE7 in order to download Firefox/Opera/whatever. By then, they'll probably just settle with IE7 since it has tabs...


@Rumor Debunking: No Gears of War for PC:
It's only a matter of time before all Windows games are only made for Microsoft Xbox 2009 system, leaving Windows to only be used for spreadsheets and "enterprise" applications.

Macs have few games (though my wife and I play WoW on our Macs, so we're set), but when you stop playing games, Macs can do much more. iLife gives you the power to explore and create great things with your digital media. Macs also have industry leading software that can lay out a newspaper, magazine, or produce motion pictures and studio albums.

And they can still do Excel.

A Windows PC without its games is just a corporate, lifeless box.

@Zune:
"Buy it ... and you are dumb."

Paul, I couldn't have said it better myself. Getting a Zune is almost as dumb as MS fanbois using Windows Live Search because its a Microsoft search engine.

Also dumb: iPod owners who refuse to use iTunes to manage it, then complain that their iPod experience is sub-par.

vandil2 November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"I've been pretty critical of Microsoft's Zune because the device is a half-hearted attempt at wresting control away from Apple's iPod at a time when Microsoft really needs a home run."

That's just plain stupidity. Sometimes it's better to get a few hits than to go for a home-run. Yes, you've been critical of Zune, one of the reasons being that it doesn't support the iTunes music store... WOW, really??? Who would've imagined that, Paul? It's too early to write an epitaph for Zune in my opinion. I don't know if Zune will end up being successful in the long run but I think it's too early to write it off.

Regarding the comment by vandil/ bonch/ whatever about a Windows PC being a "corporate, lifeless box," does that mean you've changed your tune now? Didn't you used to say Macs were for getting the real work done while PCs are for playing Sims? Hmmm...

shark47 November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


@shark47

Make no mistake. Windows PCs, gaming aside, are for corporation to use for working with Microsoft Office, applications that require IE6/7-on-Windows, legacy applications that require DOS/Win16/Win32 APIs, and other "enterprise" software that's Windows-only.

It's all corporate business bookkeeping crap that lifeless "Directors" and execs use, trying to pretend that they're living in a digital lifestyle because they have the batman belt of Windows Mobile phones to play with Excel and Outlook on the toilet.


In the workplace, Macs can do spreadsheets, too. But they are primarily called upon to do the heavy, time-sensitive lifting of: movie post-production, studio album recording, DVD mastering, layout of print advertisements and sales papers, layout of almost every major newspaper and magazine, and powering the supercomputers at a few major Universities.

All without the risk of viruses and spyware. Ever. Not even the hassles of preventative maintenance!

Windows PCs at work: Excel, Oracle, The Sims, viruses and spyware.

Macs: For getting real work done, without ANY hassles.

vandil2 November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


Most computer users(Window or Mac) don't ever do:

"movie post-production, studio album recording, DVD mastering, layout of print advertisements and sales papers, layout of almost every major newspaper and magazine, and powering the supercomputers at a few major Universities."

mtkates November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


"But they are primarily called upon to do the heavy, time-sensitive lifting of: movie post-production, studio album recording, DVD mastering, layout of print advertisements and sales papers, layout of almost every major newspaper and magazine, and powering the supercomputers at a few major Universities."

They are also used to alter time, halt the speed of light, not to mention doing all the household chores!

Vandil, that *one* industry. Movie studios use multiple OS's; ILM, *the* standard in CGI, uses custom software they developed for Linux.

DVD recording is *so* difficult, I can't do it on my PC! It just stresses my PC too much. </sarcasm>.

By a *few* universities, I assume you mean in the single digits? Most universities either use Linux or Windows. The art department might use Macs, but the engineering department *will* *not* *ever* use macs.

The industry I'm in uses Windows for client PCs and Unix for the production database. Period. It is a manufacturing environment. Big, tough factory workers (some I would classify as thugs!) could not be *paid* to work with a "pretty" UI. They prefer the "ugly" grays of Windows Classic. The day they use macs will be, um, I can't think of one.

This past Sunday, I had to use OS X to transfer a file to my flash drive (I was at someone else's house). Trying to be as open-minded as possible, I was struck by how slow and bloated OS X felt. 5-10 seconds to open Safari? The same amount to open the Finder? *Why* can't I see the folder structure? Why must they make it so difficult to tell when your USB drive is "ejected?" Why no fullscreen? On the app I was using, it was slower than the same app ported to Windows (it was flash-based). While I was waiting for it to close, it alternated between the SBBOD (spinning beach ball of doom) and the watch.
Ejecting a USB drive was also twice as slow as ejecting it in Windows.

I am willing to blame it on the 6-month old Macbook, though.

NateB2 November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


@mtkates
"Most computer users(Window or Mac) don't ever do.."

Welcome to the thread. Please start by reading the part where we're talking about IN THE WORKPLACE. Thanks.

vandil2 November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


I've always felt a sense of slow degradation in the past when using Apple software which is why I didn't stick with it for very long. Windows isn't much better but at least it is tweakable in a more friendly kind of way. But Linux is a breath of fresh air both in maintenance and in transferring files from system to system. 6 months ago I would have written off Linux as pure blarney, but now I am sold in all aspects of computer environments.

treeorc November 22, 2006 (Article Rating: )


 See More Comments  1   2   3   4   5   6 

You must be a registered user or online subscriber to comment on this article. Please log on before posting a comment. Are you a new visitor? Register now




Top Viewed ArticlesView all articles
WinInfo Short Takes: Week of November 9, 2009

An often irreverent look at some of the week's other news, including some more Windows 7 sales momentum, some Sophos stupidity, Microsoft's cloud computing self-loathing, more whining from the browser makers, Zoho's "Fake Office," and much, much more ...

Command Prompt Tricks

One reader shares his tip for setting up the command prompt to reflect a remote path. ...

Windows 7 Sets Sales Record

Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer described Windows 7's first ten days of sales as "fantastic" while in Japan yesterday. ...


Related Events Check out our list of Free Email Newsletters!

News and Analysis eBooks Getting Maximum Performance from Your Web-based Applications

Business Process Automation - Managing Cost in Your Enterprise

Related News and Analysis Resources Introducing Left-Brain.com, the online IT bookstore
Looking for books, CDs, toolkits, eBooks? Prime your mind at Left-Brain.com

Discover Windows IT Pro eLearning Series!
Clear & detailed technical information and helpful how-to's, all in our trademark no-nonsense format


Windows IT Pro Home Register FAQ for Windows WinInfo News
Europe Edition About Us Contact Us/Customer Service Media Kit Affiliates / Licensing  
SQL Server Magazine Office & SharePoint Pro DevProConnections IT Job Hound
Left-Brain.com Technology Resource Directory asp.netPRO ITTV Windows SuperSite 
 
 Windows IT Pro is a Division of Penton Media Inc.
 © 2009 Penton Media, Inc. Terms of Use | Privacy Statement